Work

Reply to Trask

Year: 1991
Type: letter
Abstract: Oince Trask's vituperative commentary so strikingly exemplifies and hence reinforces many of the themes of my paper, my initial reaction was to decline to reply (other than, perhaps, to invite the reader to ponder which of us is a racist). However, I have been persuaded that some of the issues merit further debate and clarification. With regard to my own politics, in relation to issues of past colonial invasion (including missionary invasion), present neocolonialism and global capitalism, gender, and the struggles of Third and Fourth World peoples, I have been consistent, outspoken, and unequivocal in precept and practice. I feel no need to defend my track record on these issues (it is at least a change to be criticized for being too reactionary instead of for being too radical). The stark insider versus outsider dichotomy drawn in Trask's rhetoric troubles me for other reasons. It strikes me as a great leap backward in what purports to be radical discourse, a quarter century out of date. The time is long past where those who are friends of Pacific Islanders and islands and those who are enemies can be sorted out on the basis of their genes or skin colors: there are plenty of insiders, many with Swiss bank accounts, busily selling their forests, their minerals, their fish—the lives and environments of their village cousins and their own children and grandchildren—to foreign interests. The battle lines in the contemporary Pacific have more to do with issues of class and interest (as Epeli Hau'ofa has powerfully argued [1987]) than with issues of culture or skin color; in fact, cultural nationalist rhetoric is increas ingly deployed by Pacific elites to camouflage these issues of power and interest.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W91235251
Cites: 2
Cited by: 32
Related to: 10