Work

Jaspers’ Dilemma: The Psychopathological Challenge to Subjectivity Theories of Consciousness

Year: 2015
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: Alexandre Billon and Uriah Kriegel, the chapter authors, hold that our conscious states often have a distinctive subjective character, or “mine-ness,” in virtue of which they appear to us to be ours. According to what they call “subjectivity theories,” the connection between phenomenal consciousness and subjective character is necessary: all phenomenally conscious states must exhibit this mine-ness. Such theories include higher-order and self-representational theories. Billon and Kriegel consider a prima facie threat to subjectivity theories from cases of patients suffering from thought insertion, delusions of alien control, somatoparaphrenia, and depersonalization who would seem to have conscious thoughts, intentions, or bodily sensations that lack subjective character. They argue that at least some subjectivity theories can accommodate these pathologies.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W931676655
FWCI: 21.01
Cites: 37
Cited by: 78
Related to: 9