Assessing Parallel Explanations: A Method for Disentangling Competing Explanations in Qualitative International Relations Research
Year: 2011
Type: preprint
Abstract: Because of the complexity of social life, most topics of interest to political scientists have numerous compelling explanations. Moreover, in many cases the alternative explanations not only point to the same behavior, but contribute partially to the outcome. Such instances of parallel explanations for a phenomenon can greatly complicate qualitative analysis. This is a problem throughout social science but occurs frequently in international relations, particularly in the debate between material and ideational causes in state behavior; in many cases. Quantitative studies can draw on large sample sizes to control for variation in alternative explanations, but the nature of qualitative analysis makes the use of such techniques difficult. And existing qualitative methods often require more data than is available in many international relations cases or struggle to deal with the problem of parallel explanations. This paper presents a method through which this problem can be addressed by drawing from work in the field of comparative historical analysis. This method of parallel causal elaboration helps to structure relationships among possible causal factors and competing theories to enable the resolution of the problem of parallel explanations. The paper applies the method to the case of the end of the Cold War.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Author: Peter S. Henne
Institution: Pew Research Center
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W102412824
