Year: 2013
Type: article
Abstract: My son is six. He is a really good kid (if I do say so myself ); he is friendly, respectful, funny, and smart. At home we struggle with the same sorts of issues as other parents of six-year-olds. He does not always listen, he whines, and he complains. His room is often messy, and when we point out that there are things still on the floor, waiting to be put away, he complains that he did not see those things the first time around. He stuffs food in his mouth, and hates to use utensils. He is a picky eater, preferring food that looks pretty much like how it grew out of the ground or walked on the earth, with little to no modification before it reaches his plate. He chews on things, including toys and his clothes. He also gets joy out of annoying his little sister. 2 At home, these things are all minor annoyances, and seemingly not much to worry about. At school he reads two grade levels above his first grade peers, and his math skills are excellent. He has friends that live next door to us, and they frequently knock on our door to see if he can come out and play. At home, he is just a normal kid who has some quirks. But at school, my little black boy has “worrisome” behaviors. The chewing indicates stress or anxiety. His messiness indicates poor motor planning. His pickiness indicates an oral hypersensitivity. His tendency to bump into people, including annoying his little sister, indicates a spatial recognition disorder. Despite his superior academic skills, his teachers have contacted me for informal meetings several times these past two years. Even the principal suggested convening a Student Study Team, or “SST,” which is a step that could possibly lead to assessment, labeling, and placement in a special education program for children with disabilities. If my son were not black, it is possible that I would take the school’s concern for his well being as a welcome opportunity to partner for the betterment of my child. But he is black, and so I am wary. Nationally, black children are significantly more likely than other children to be in special education. Black children are 17% of the public school population, but represent about a quarter of all children receiving special education services. In addition, they are three times as likely to be labeled mentally retarded (“MR”) and twice as likely to be labeled emotionally disturbed (“ED”). As I discuss below, these two diagnoses are associated with particularly negative in-school and post-school outcomes. Black children are underrepresented among those diagnosed with autism and speech/ language disorders, and approximately equally represented in the other categories of disability. These trends, however, are uneven in school districts across the country. Racial disproportionality in special education is greatest where one might least expect to find it, in middle income or affluent districts with a relatively low proportion of black students and a high proportion of white students – exactly the type of district in which my family lives. While special education may be useful for some children, outcomes for black children are markedly negative. Placement in special education can lead to in-school racial segregation through the use of “special day classes.” In addition to the social isolation, black children in special education have less access to the general curriculum, making it more difficult for them to continue their education past the twelfth grade; indeed, many black children receiving special educational services fail to receive a regular high school diploma, and more of them drop out of school altogether than receive a regular diploma.
Source: The Modern American
Author: LaToya Baldwin Clark
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W109356
