All the Way Down the Slippery Slope: Gun Prohibition in England and Some Lessons for Civil Liberties in America
Year: 1999
Type: preprint
Abstract: Whenever civil liberties issues are contested, proponents of greater restrictions often chide civil liberties defenders for being unwilling to offer concessions. Frequently, persons advocating restrictions on civil liberties claim that the moderate restriction will not infringe the core civil liberty. When rights advocates raise the slope argument, they are criticized for being excessively fearful. The goal of the article is to refine our understanding of slopes by examining a case in which a civil liberty really did slide all the way down the slippery slope. The right to arms in Great Britain was entirely unrestricted at the beginning of the twentieth century; as the century ends, the right is dead, and only a feeble, severely constricted privilege to possess certain sporting guns remains. The article examines, step-by step, how Britain moved from a strong, unfettered right to near-total prohibition of that right. While each of Britain's incremental steps towards gun control was, in itself, reasonable, the cumulative effect was to destroy the right gradually. Although the right to arms is the focus of the article, the article also discusses many other civil liberties, and their fate in twentieth century Britain and America. The article concludes that, in light of historical experience, organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union and the National Rifle Association of America, which vigorously resist even the smallest perceived infringements on constitutional rights, may be acting prudently in the long term, even though their no concessions stance may appear unreasonable in the short term.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Authors: David B. Kopel, Joseph Edward Olson
Institutions: Cato Institute, University of Denver, Hamline University
Language: English
Topic: Law, Rights, and Freedoms
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W120796889
