Work

Queensland Government Actions to Compensate Survivors of Institutional Abuse: A Critical and Comparative Evaluation

Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: Governments in a number of jurisdictions have responded to revelations of sustained abuse and neglect of children in State institutions by establishing schemes awarding financial compensation to survivors, and amending limitation statutes to enable the commencement of civil proceedings.In 1999, the Forde Commission of Inquiry into Abuse of Children in Queensland Institutions reported a similarly devastating incidence of abuse and neglect, and its recommendations included the establishment by the Queensland government of a monetary compensation scheme.This article contrasts the Queensland government's calculated failure to respond to this recommendation, and its antithetical personal injuries legislation, with the actions of its counterparts.1 Most commonly, this abuse and neglect has been perpetrated by individuals within families, but it has also been perpetrated on children entrusted to the care of government and religious institutions.It is only in the last few decades that this incidence of abuse and neglect of children in State and religious institutions has begun to be revealed.In a number of jurisdictions, bodies of inquiry have discovered appalling records of institutional abuse and neglect of children. 2 In Queensland, the Forde Commission of Inquiry into Abuse of Children in Institutions was commendably established by the Queensland government on 13 August 1998 after growing evidence of abuse of children in State and religious institutions.3 The Forde Inquiry found endemic emotional, physical, sexual and systems abuse, as well as breaches of statutory obligations to provide food, clothing, education and appropriate discipline.4 Tragically, after the Forde which gave a father dominion over his children (and his wife).The extent of this power was such that in early Roman law the father had the right to abandon infants to the elements: A Borkowski, Textbook on Roman Law, Blackstone Press, London, 1994, 103; J Gardner, Women in Roman Law and Society, Routledge, London, 1986, 155.A father had the right to punish his children, which could include imposing a penalty of death: Gardner, 6-7; and the right to sell his children; from at least the seventh century a father could legally sell his children aged under seven: P Thane, 'Childhood in History', in M King (ed), Childhood, Welfare & Justice, Batsford, London, 1981, 12. 2 In Canada, for example, New Brunswick established its compensation scheme in 1995 after it commissioned the Miller Inquiry in 1992, the government of British Columbia established its compensation scheme in 1995 after it commissioned the Berger Report in 1993, and Nova Scotia established its compensation program in 1996 after its Stratton Inquiry found that the State had a moral obligation to respond to the claims of victims: G Shea, Redress Programs Relating to Institutional Child Abuse in Canada (1999) Ottawa: Law Commission of Canada <http://www.lcc.gc.ca/en/themes/mr/ica/shea/redress/redress_main.asp> at 31 January 2004.In Ireland in 1970, the Kennedy Report first investigated State-run and State-certified reformatories and industrial schools and uncovered the problems of neglect, deprivation and emotional abuse.In 1999, Prime Minister Bertie Ahern introduced several strategies to address more recent revelations of child abuse in State institutions, including the establishment of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse, chaired by Justice Laffoy, which is due to report in 2005: Ireland, Compensation Advisory Committee, Towards Redress And Recovery: Report To The Minister For Education And Science, 2002, <http://www.rirb.ie/documents/cac_report2002.pdf> at 31 January 2004 (hereafter referred to as Towards Redress And Recovery).3
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W12713288
FWCI: 0.798
Cites:
Cited by: 10
Related to: 10