Positive Thinking. Conceptions of Negative Quantities in the Netherlands and the Reception of Lacroix's Algebra Textbook
Year: 2018
Type: article
Abstract: The beginning of the 19th century witnessed the emergence of several new approaches to negative numbers.New notions of rigour made the 18th century conceptions of negative quantities unacceptable.This paper discusses theories of negative numbers emerging in the Netherlands in the early 19th century.Dutch mathematicians then opted for a different approach than that of their contemporaries, in Germany or France.The Dutch translation (1821) of Lacroix's Élémens d'algèbre illustrates the 'Dutch' notion of rigour. R ÉSUM É. -PENSER POSITIVEMENT. CONCEPTION DES NOMBRES N ÉGA-TIFS AUX PAYS-BAS ET R ÉCEPTION DU TRAIT É D'ALG ÈBRE DE LACROIX.-Au début du XIX e siècle, des attitudes nouvelles par rapport aux nombres négatifs émergent.La notion de rigueur en mathématique se renouvelle, rendant inacceptables les approches qui s'étaient développées au XVIII e siècle.Cet article présente les théories des nombres négatifs qui avaient cours aux Pays-bas au début du XIX e siècle.Les mathématiciens néerlandais optaient pour une conception différente de celles de leurs contemporains en Allemagne et en France.La traduction néerlandaise des Elémens d'algèbre de Lacroix illustrera cette approche néerlandaise de la notion de rigueur.Mathematical theories developed around 1800 were not readily accepted, and mathematics in the various European countries met with rather different epistemological approaches.Different institutional contexts, where mathematical knowledge was pursued in France and Germany for instance, gave rise to different notions of rigour [Schubring 1996].Sylvestre F. Lacroix's textbooks provide examples to test this assertion, as they were very popular in France and kept in line with the ideas of (*)
DOI: 10.24033/rhm.97
Author: Danny J. Beckers
Language: English
Subfield: History and Philosophy of Science
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1466089395
