Freedom or Theocracy? Constitutionalism in Afghanistan and Iraq
Year: 2005
Type: article
Abstract: Afghans are victims of the games superpowers once played: their war was once our war, and collectively we bear responsibility." 1 "In the approved version of the [Afghan] constitution, Article 3 was amended to read, 'In Afghanistan, no law can be contrary to the beliefs and provisions of the sacred religion of Islam.' … This very significant clause basically gives the official and nonofficial religious leaders in Afghanistan sway over every action that they might deem contrary to their beliefs, which by extension and within the Afghan cultural context, could be regarded as 'beliefs' of Islam." 2 "The lopsided [electoral] victory by Iraq's Shiite Muslim alliance gives it the biggest voice in shaping the nation's new government and constitution….Will Sharia, or Islamic law, become the main reference for national policy on divorce, censorship, the role of women in society, broadcasting and public morality, as many Shiite clerics and their followers insist?" 3 longer "be treated as second-class Muslims."27 In 1921, he enacted a Family Code banning child marriage, marriages between close relatives, excessive dowries, and the exchange of women as "blood money" in payment of interfamilial disputes.28 He opened girls' schools and sent women students abroad for higher education.29 After 1923, the Amir introduced Afghanistan's first civil code, 30 which abolished polygamy and marriages to all girls under the age of 18. 31 His wife Soraya appeared unveiled in public and participated actively in politics, citing the example of women in the "early years of Islam."32 ¶11 Not satisfied with the constitution's gestures towards theocracy, and disappointed with King Amanullah's record as the "protector" of Islam, Afghanistan's religious elite quickly moved to overthrow and reverse his modernizing reforms.The head of a prominent religious family, which served as "king makers" in Afghan society, 33 immediately denounced the 1923 constitution as a "communist" document.34 A rebellion reached the outskirts of the capital Kabul, and was only repelled when the Amir mobilized his new air force to strafe and bomb the advancing insurgents, 35 and then executed the revolt's leaders.36 ¶12Rebels having nearly toppled his regime, the Amir called a Loya Jirga to amend the 1923 constitution in several important respects designed to pacify Afghanistan's religious elite.37 One amendment made the Hanafi school of Islamic law the official religious rite of Afghanistan.38 Additional concessions from the Amir included "watering down" the rights of women, 39 reintroducing torture when "in accordance with the rules of the Sharia," 40 and allowing a Council of Islamic Scholars to "decide whether new laws were in accordance with Islamic law." 41 ¶13 After Amir Amanullah became King of Afghanistan in 1926, he announced further sweeping reforms aimed at helping Afghan women.42 He endorsed expanding Afghan girls' access to education, proclaimed his opposition to the compulsory veiling of women, and imposed Western dress within the capital of Kabul.43 In response, Afghan religious leaders once again led conservative Afghan tribes in rebellion.Under siege, King Amanullah abdicated the throne in early 1929.44 Historians tend to blame the King's overhasty reforms for his downfall, especially those dealing with mandatory veiling, the seclusion of women, and forced and underage marriages.45 But the West failed to support the King who admired its values, and Britain actively worked to overthrow him.Many Afghans and even the British press believed that the British Empire was behind Amanullah's fall from power, given the Empire's poor relations with him.46 ¶14 King Amanullah's successors quickly overturned his reforms.But in doing so, they did not return Afghanistan to a pre-modern or pre-constitutional condition.Instead, they established an Islamic constitutional monarchy that, despite its theocratic aspects, also retained some of the 1923 constitution's gestures towards reform. ¶15A Loya Jirga in 1930 created Afghanistan's next stable government and pronounced Nadir Shah as Afghanistan's King.47 The King promulgated the second Afghan constitution in 1931.48 With a few minor changes, it endured as Afghanistan's governing charter for more than 30 years.49 Like the 1923 constitution, it embraced tradition while looking tentatively towards the future.On the side of tradition, it made the Hanafi school of Islam the state religion, established a requirement that all legislation conform to the Sharia, and gave religious authorities the power to review Afghan laws and governmental policies for correspondence to Sharia law.50 But it also guaranteed compulsory elementary education, freedom of the press within the limits of the Sharia, and a limited role for democratically elected officials to participate in the drafting of legislation.51 Afghan women became eligible to vote in elections, although the authorities later declared this provision to be incompatible with Islamic law.
Source: FIU Law Review
Author: Hannibal Travis
Institution: Florida International University
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1479924685
