Work

Appellate Courts as First Responders: The Constitutionality and Propriety of Appellate Courts' Resolving Issues in the First Instance

Year: 2011
Type: article
Abstract: In designing court systems in this country, all of the states and the federal government have created trial courts and one or more levels of appellate courts.Legal professionals, litigants, and the people of this country in general typically conceive of appellate courts as courts of review, courts that review decisions made by trial court judges, by decision makers in administrative agencies, or occasionally by arbitrators.We view it to be the role of trial judges and juries, administrative agencies, and arbitrators-not appellate courts-to make the initial findings of fact, reach the initial conclusions of law, apply the law to the facts in the first instance, and exercise discretion as to issues, raised in the foundational proceeding, whose resolution is not dictated by rules of law.We then see it as the function of courts of appeals acting as such to re-examine fact-findings, conclusions of law, applications of law to fact, and exercises of discretion under appropri- 2012 Joan S.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1501964310
FWCI: 2.511
Cites:
Cited by: 5
Related to: 9