Surface-water hydrology and runoff simulations for three basins in Pierce County, Washington
Year: 1996
Type: report
Abstract: study area Conceptual model Surface retention Flow from hillslopes --------Horton overland flow Saturated overland flow Subsurface flow ,--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Flow in channelsInteraction of surface water with ground water 10 Generalizations about runoff in the study area 10 Simulation of runoffDescription of the numerical model Impervious land segments Pervious land segments 14 Channel network Construction of numerical basin models Subbasins Land segments Reaches 26 Network--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Calibration of thenumerical model 30 Data collection Catchment studies and the rural basin Basin calibration Results from runoff simulations 56 Precipitation patterns 56 Comparison of simulated and observed runoff Annual and seasonal runoff 62 Peak discharges and storm runoff volumes 76 Daily mean discharges Sources of errors Annual distribution of runoff by the basin models Long-term simulation 97 Summary References cited 101 Supplementary data 103 inFIGURES 1. Map showing study area location, basin boundaries, and creeks in the study area in Pierce County, Wash. 2. Flowchart of simulated runoff from pervious land segments 3. Map showing subbasin divisions, channel reaches, streamflow gages, and rain gages for the (a) Clear-darks Basin model and (b) Clover Creek Basin model 4. Map showing distribution of till, outwash, and saturated land segments in the study area in Pierce County, Wash. ----------------------------------------5. Schematic diagram of thenetwork design for the (a) Clear-Clarks Basin model and (b) Clover Creek Basin model 6.Map showing the Cow Pasture Catchment, altitude contours, and the location of the soil-moisture sites, rain gage, and streamflow gage-7-8.Annual hydrograph showing: 7. Observed and simulated discharge at the Rural Basin, preliminary calibration model run, and rainfall recorded at the Canyon Road gage 8. Observed and simulated discharge at the Rural Basin, final calibration model run, and rainfall recorded at the Canyon Road gage 41 9. Storm hydrographs of observed discharge with the preliminary and final calibrated simulations for the Rural Basin and rainfall at the Canyon Road gage-10-15.Hydrographs showing: 10.Simulated soil moisture for the saturated land segment and observed available soil moisture at site Tl.bot 11.Simulated soil moisture for the till-grass-flat land segment and observed available soil moisture at all sites except site Tl.bot 12. Simulated storm runoff and various components of flow from till-forest-flat and till-grass-flat land segments and rainfall from the Canyon Road gage 13.Simulated storm runoff and various components of flow from saturated and outwash-grass land segments and rainfall from the Canyon Road gage 14.Simulated and observed discharge at Clear Creek at Pioneer Way for the preliminary and final calibration model runs and rainfall at the Canyon Road gage 15.Preliminary and final calibration model runs at Clear Creek at 100th Street East, observed and simulated discharge and channel losses for Clear Creek at Pioneer Way, and rainfall at the Canyon Road gage 16.Graphs showing monthly normal precipitation and monthly precipitation for water years 1990-92 at McMillin Reservoir and observed monthly precipitation at the Canyon Road gage-61 17-26.Annual hydrographs of observed and simulated daily mean discharge and daily rainfall: 17.For station 12090340 and for station 470948122211801 18.For station 12090355 and for station 470532122223901 19.For station 12090365 and for station 470948122211801 20.For station 12090380 and for station 470948122211801 21.For station 12090400 and for station 470948122211801 22.For station 12090500 and for station 470711122263201 23.For station 12102025 and for station 470948122211801 24.For station 12102140 and for station 471242122232201 25.For station 12102190 and for station 470948122211801 26.For station 12102212 and for station 471242122232201 27.Graphs showing observed and simulated annual runoff, seasonal runoff, storm runoff, and peak discharge data for all of the continuous-recording stream-gage sites in the study area IV FIGURES-Continued 28-31.Hydrographs showing observed and simulated discharge and rainfall recorded at the Canyon Road gage for: 28.Swan Creek at 80th Street East and Swan Creek at Pioneer Way, for the January 5-10, 1990, storm 83 29.Swan Creek at 80th Street East and Swan Creek at Pioneer Way, for the April 2-6, 1991, storm 84 30.Clover Creek at 25th Avenue East and Clover Creek near Tillicum, for the February 18-21, 1991, storm ---------85 31.Clover Creek at 25th Avenue East and Clover Creek near Tillicum, for the April 2-6, 1991, storm----------------86 did not always accurately simulate the correct storm hydrograph shape at two Clover Creek sites where most of the storm-water discharge is ground water.Results indicate that the models accurately simulate the important runoff processes in the study area and therefore confirm the validity of the conceptual model.Observed and simulated streamflows were compared for all the stream gaging stations.For the second year of comparisons, the validation period, the largest difference between simulated annual runoff and observed annual runoff was 2.72 inches or 25.7 percent for one of the catchment sites, and the differences for the remainder of sites ranged from -12.0 to 15.8 percent.Percentage differences for winter and spring runoff range from -28.9 to 42.2 percent.Percentage differences for summer runoff are the highest, although actual differences are low; the highest percentage difference is 700 percent, representing an actual difference of only 0.07 inch.Two thirds of the percentage differences between simulated and observed peak flows for the three largest peaks of the water year at each station were less than 27 percent.Percentage differences between simulated and observed storm runoff volumes for the three largest storms at the continuous-recording streamflow stations ranged from -22.9 to 84.6 percent, with two-thirds of the differences being less than 19 percent.Percentage differences between simulated and observed daily mean discharges had absolute errors ranging from 8.6 to 197.7 percent.Long-term simulations of 30 and 31 years confirmed the stability of the models by not simulating unreasonable ranges of volumes in the simulated ground-water reservoirs or unreasonable peak streamflows.The author extends appreciation to the Pierce County Storm Drainage and Surface Water Management Utility for its assistance in collecting streamflow data and providing much of the available mapping data.The author also wishes to acknowledge the citizens of Pierce County who allowed access on their property to install and maintain gages and those who diligently collected gage heights on a daily basis. DESCRIPTION OF THE STUDY AREAThe three drainage basins that define the study area all share common boundaries and are located in central Pierce County, Wash., at the southeastern end of the Puget Sound Lowland region (fig.1).The Clear Creek drainage basin has two separate creeks, Swan Creek and Clear Creek, with a combined drainage area of 6.53 square miles.The Clarks Creek Basin has three separate creeks, Canyon Creek, West Fork Clarks Creek (also referred to as Rody Creek), and Diru Creek, with a combined drainage area of 4.51 square miles.The Clover Creek drainage basin contains several creeks that all drain into Clover Creek, with a combined drainage area of 75.9 square miles.The major streams in the Clover Creek Basin besides Clover Creek include Spanaway Creek, Morey Creek (a distributary from Spanaway Creek), and the North Fork of Clover Creek.Spanaway Lake on Spanaway Creek, which contains about 4,600 acre-feet, is the only large lake in the study area.Warm, dry summers and cool, wet winters characterize the climate of the study area.The mean monthly January temperature for the period 1951-80 was 37°F at McMillin Reservoir, a long-term weather station located 2 miles east of the study area.The mean monthly temperature for July and August, the two warmest months, is 63°F.The mean annual precipitation is 41.40 inches, and 78 percent of the precipitation falls from October through April (U.S.Department of Commerce, 1982).Typical rain storms of the region arrive from the west or southwest as large frontal storms of low intensity and long duration.Snow falls rarely and does not contribute substantially to the total annual precipitation, so snowfall was not considered in the description of the runoff processes or addressed in the runoff simulations in this study.The study basins have complex sets of physical features that overlay each other.These features include changing topography, varied distribution of soils, and a non-uniform pattern of land cover resulting from the land use and settlement patterns of the region.The result is that a large number of land types, each having a unique runoff response to rainfall, are distributed throughout the basins.In the southern and western portion of the study area, the landforms and their hydrologic characteristics are dominated by a glacial outwash deposit known as the Steilacoom Gravels.This outwash deposit has consistently coarse gravels, generally 20 feet thick or less.It is believed to have been formed during the release of water from Lake Puyallup, a Pleistocene glacial lake, during the retreat of the glacier (Walters and Kimmel, 1968).The soil is so well drained that in undeveloped areas there are no surface-water drainage channels other than the two main creeks, the main stem of Clover Creek and Spanaway Creek, which both emerge from springs.Soils that formed over the Steilacoom Gravels are identified with the group classified as the Spanaway Soil association (U.S.Department of Agriculture, 1979).The Steilacoom Gravels form a large flat plain containing several small lakes and one large lake, Spa
DOI: 10.3133/wri954068
Author: M.C. Mastin
Language: English
Subfield: Water Science and Technology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: gold
OpenAlex ID: W1577835717
