A Time for Reform: Allowing a Hybrid Exemption Under the Investment Company Act of 1940
Year: 2008
Type: preprint
Abstract: A Time for Reform: Allowing a Hybrid Exemption under the Investment Company Act of 1940 Under the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC or Commission) current regulatory regime, many private equity funds and hedge funds are left with a difficult choice. To qualify for an exemption under the Investment Company Act of 1940 (Investment Company Act), funds must either admit no more than 100 investors, or must be composed solely of “qualified purchasers” (minimum of $5 million in investments for natural persons). To maximize fund size, fund managers generally choose to arrange their fund in a Section 3(c)(7) world with “qualified purchasers,” but this means that fund managers are left in the position where they must turn away potential investors who do not have adequate capital to be considered “qualified purchasers.”This policy has left many fund managers wondering why they must decide what exemption box in which to place their funds. Similarly, investors wonder why there cannot be some sort of hybrid exemption between Sections 3(c)(1) and 3(c)(7), which would allow the inclusion of a limited number of “accredited investors” as well as “qualified purchasers” in one fund. Recently, in a no-action letter dated July 9, 2008, The Townsend Group, Inc. (Townsend) asked the SEC to reconsider this policy. In denying Townsend’s request, the SEC relied in part on its rejection in 1992 of a similar - although different - proposal. In its Protecting Investors report, the SEC chose not to recommend a mechanism that would exclude “sophisticated investors” from the 100 investor limit in 3(c)(1) funds. he discussion is sparse, stating that “the 100 investor limit in the current private investment company exception reasonably reflects the point at which federal regulatory concerns are raised if any unsophisticated investors are involved.” We don’t disagree with that statement, or that passing 3(c)(7) was a better solution at that time. But as the private equity and hedge fund world has grown up around us in the past 15 years, it doesn’t provide a reasoned response why permitting an unlimited number of 3(c)(7) “qualified purchasers” into a 3(c)(1) “accredited investor” fund wouldn’t be an acceptable next step in the evolution of Investment Company Act exemptive relief. Townsend approached the SEC in hopes that the SEC would reconsider its policy. Townsend manages two parallel private equity funds. One of these funds qualifies for an exemption under Section 3(c)(1), while the other qualifies for an exemption under Section 3(c)(7). Townsend proposed merging these two funds into a combined fund (3(c)(1) Plus Fund). This fund would be limited to no more than 100 “accredited investor” beneficial owners that are not “qualified purchasers” and an unlimited number of “qualified purchaser” beneficial owners. The cost savings from not having to administer two vehicles would be material to the 3(c)(1) investors (and marginal, although still a savings, for the 3(c)(7) investors). The SEC concluded that it could not assure Townsend that it would not recommend enforcement. Given that the SEC chose not to recommend excluding “sophisticated investors” from the 100 investor limit in 3(c)(1) funds in Protecting Investors (which was a recommendation for amendment), it is possible that the SEC views the requested no-action assurance as beyond its interpretive purview. We respectfully disagree with the conclusion; either way, this article advocates that the ruleshould be changed.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Authors: Addison D. Braendel, Seth Chertok, Martin Rosenberg, Matthew Gaudette
Language: English
Subfield: Finance
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1591790337
