Work

The Practice of the International Criminal Court: Comments on the Complementarity Conundrum

Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: Professor Michael Newton advocates for the International Criminal Court (ICC) to proactively adopt positive complementarity, rather than continue the apparent trend toward supranational superiority that endangers the principle of complementarity and the ICC itself This article explores Newton's concerns over potential ICC hostility to state action in several areas.After closely examining ICC practice and offering alternate interpretations of allegedly problematic positions taken by the ICC, this article concludes that the evidence is mixed While some ICC practice supports Newton's concerns, it is not clear that the most troublesome positions will apply outside the narrow context of self-referring, inactive states.Where states profess no desire to take action against the accused, it is difficult to extrapolate from ICC decisions on admissibility, statements on gravity, or other issues related to complementarity.Nonetheless, there are sufficient indications of apparent hostility or indifference to state sovereignty to raise concerns.
Author: Linda M. Keller
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1607487271
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 36
Related to: 10