Work

Case C-176/03, Commission v. Council

Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: Case C-176/03, Commission v. Council, judgment of the Grand Chamber of 13 September 2005, nyr this case, Article 7 required sanctions that are effective, proportionate and dissuasive and that include criminal or non-criminal fines.In both types of cases, other sanctions, of which the Framework Decision gave examples, were also possible.The Framework Decision was adopted on the basis of Articles 29, 31(e) and 34(2)(b) TEU (pre-Nice version).8 As for the legislative procedure, Article 34(2) TEU required unanimous voting in the Council; the European Parliament was consulted.However, by acting within the framework of the EU's third pillar the Council disregarded a proposal for a Community Directive on the protection of the environment through criminal law that had been presented by the Commission in 2001.The proposed Directive was based on the EU's first pillar, namely Article 175(1) EC (which provides for the co-decision procedure as described in Art.251 EC). 9 In the course of the procedure for the adoption of the Framework Decision, the Commission had repeatedly objected to the choice of third pillar provisions as a legal basis and insisted on Article 175 EC instead.In the Commission's view, there was room for a Framework Decision only in the sense of a measure complementing the Directive in respect to judicial cooperation in relation to the protection of the environment through criminal law, but not in relation to Articles 1 to 7 of the Framework Decision as adopted.The same view was taken by the European Parliament when it expressed its opinion on both the proposed Directive and the draft Framework Decision.However, the Council disagreed.In consideration 7 of the preamble to the Framework Decision, the Council states that it did consider the Commission's proposal but that it had "come to the conclusion that the majority required for its adoption by the Council can not be obtained.The said majority considered that the proposal went beyond the powers attributed to the Community by the Treaty establishing the European Community and that the objectives could be reached by adopting a Framework-Decision on the basis of Title VI of the Treaty on European Union.The Council also considered that the present Framework Decision, based on Article 34 of the Treaty on European Union, is a correct instrument to impose on the member States the obligation to provide for criminal sanctions.…".It was thus that the Framework Decision was adopted against the objections of both the Commission and the European Parliament.When this happened, the Commission, supported by the European Parliament, brought an action un-8.The Nice Treaty entered into force on 1 Feb. 2003 and thus a few days after the adoption of the Framework Decision.Today, the former Art.31(e) is Art.31(1)(e) TEU. 9.The proposal was much criticized; in the Dutch literature, see e.g.Buruma and Somsen, "Een strafwetgever te Brussel inzake milieubescherming?", (2001) NJB, 795-797, and M.I.Veldt Folgia, "(Nog) geen strafrecht in de Eerste Pijler?", (2002) SEW, 162-169.cola2006031.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W19148017
FWCI: 3.614
Cites:
Cited by: 16
Related to: 10