Work

'Ireland mustn't be such a bad place so': Mapping the "Real" Terrain of the Aran Islands

Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: Ireland mustn't be such a bad place so': Mapping the "Real" Terrain of the Aran Islands Karen O'Brien Martin McDonagh'sThe Cripple of Inishmaan (1996) responds to and encodes the complexities of representational and ecological issues surrounding life on the rural landscape of the Aran Islands.The three islands that constitute the Aran Islands-Inisheer, Inishmaan, and Inishmore-occupy a unique and dual position of marginality and liminality; they not only reside off the border of the western coast of Ireland but also inhabit an indeterminate space between America and Europe.The archipelagos are described by Irish poet Seamus Heaney as a place "Where the land ends with a sheer drop / You can see three stepping stones out of Europe." 1 Inishmaan employs three strategic interrogations-representation, structure, and aesthetics-that coincide with the project of collaborative ecology.The first strategy juxtaposes two contrasting representations of Ireland's 1930s rural west, problematizing the notion of a definable Irishness in relation to the unique Arans landscape.Inishmaan revolves around the filming of the American documentary Man of Aran (1934), which claims authenticity in its representation of actual island residents.McDonagh's depiction of the Aran community, however, contradicts the documentary's poetic vision of the Aran Islands as a pristine landscape.In scene eight, for example, the screening of Man of Aran does not reflect a mirror image of the Aran residents represented in the play; the film, contrarily, incites mockery.Despite its claim of historical authenticity and authority, the documentary proves fictional.Inishmaan contests the legitimacy of Man of Aran explicitly as well as a history of romanticized notions of western Irish identity implicitly.McDonagh's interrogation of the ontological status of the film's authoritative narrative and imagery, furthermore, generates tension between the fictive representations that open conceptual spaces in which to negotiate alternate depictions of Aran life.The conceptual fissures, which seemingly separate, operate as points of symbiosis by way of the second interrogation, which takes the form of a structural strategy.Fixed boundaries that underscore separateness are challenged in Inishmaan through the structural engagement of opposing, fictional representations.In a similar way, the "sheer drop" of an Aran crag that physically segregates the land from sea, as Heaney observes, may be recognized, especially in the contemporary context of Celtic Tiger prosperity, as a "stepping stone" into Ireland rather than as Karen O'Brien is a Ph.D.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1956361007
FWCI:
Cites: 9
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10