Year: 2003
Type: article
Abstract: The adoption of site licenses and consortial purchasing arrangements has grown rapidly in the past 5 years to become one of the predominant ways of negotiating subscriptions to scholarly journals. Yet, to date, little qualitative or quantitative research has been undertaken to examine the impact that this form of negotiation is having within the scholarly information community. Many library users have benefited from the emergence of the so-called 'Big Deal', whereby a group of libraries pools its purchasing power through a consortium and negotiates a multi-year electronic access agreement directly with a large publisher, providing online access to much more content for a little more money. The question is, however, whether this apparent 'win–win' situation is sustainable for the publisher or the libraries involved. In 2002, the Ingenta Institute, a non-profit making organization funded by Ingenta plc, commissioned research into the impact of site licensing and consortial developments on institutions, libraries, publishers and users. The programme set out to determine what the main strategic and operational issues have been for all stakeholders, and consisted of three separate qualitative and quantitative studies focusing on the recent development and likely evolution of the terms of trade between publishers and consortia. Renowned information industry expert Professor Donald W. King of the School of Information Sciences, University of Pittsburgh, examined the impact recent electronic developments have had upon the journal system. Providing a comprehensive review of consortium licensing in the USA and outlining major trends that have occurred over the past 25 years, King draws upon his own longitudinal studies of journal usage, and upon data gained from consortia questionnaires and 15 000 surveys of US scientists. King's focus is complemented by that of UK-based research consultancy Key Perspectives, who undertook extensive studies into the impact that consortium site licenses are having on libraries and publishers. Conducting focus groups and personal interviews with an international selection of senior publishing and consortia representatives, Key Perspectives has highlighted what participants perceive to be the main issues to have emerged from consortia purchasing. To gain a more thorough and quantitative understanding of the impact that the Big Deal and site licenses are having upon patterns of user behaviour, the Institute also commissioned the Centre for Information Behaviour and the Ana-lysis of Research (CiBER) of City University, London, to study site licensing and consortia developments from the user's perspective. Led by David Nicholas, the CiBER programme is analysing usage data from two international publishers. The research aims to map the digital information-seeking behaviour of consortial license users, and has measured the digital 'fingerprints' of tens of thousands of users from around the world, approximately 50 000 of whom were Big Deal subscribers. Preliminary results from the first stage of the research programme provide some powerful new insights into the way this market is evolving and what the future might hold for this purchasing model. While consortia have long been part of the library landscape, particularly in the US, where some date back over a hundred years, it is only in the last 4–5 years that there has been rapid growth in consortia whose primary purpose is to wield collective bargaining power in the purchase of online content. This in large part has been stimulated by developments in technology that have led to the online dissemination of scholarly information, and was underpinned by the extra funding made available to libraries to enable them to participate in 'Big Deal' offers. Similarly, although publishers have offered site licenses for many years, they have only recently provided special consortial arrangements in which groups of libraries gain access to bundled collections of content. Having already established the infrastructure to deliver electronic content to their existing users, it is relatively cheap for publishers to extend access to that content to additional users, an efficient way of generating additional revenue and increasing market share. Given this short timeframe, the rate of growth in consortial licensing has been remarkably rapid. For large consortia, the number of journals delivered via the Big Deal is in the thousands, while Key Perspectives found that large and medium publishers now rely on consortia for between 24% and 58% of their revenues. Yet despite this widespread adoption, one of the main findings highlighted by the Institute research was the doubt that exists within the information community as to whether the consortial site license will prove to be an enduring and optimal model in the medium to long term. There are two basic types of consortial license deal. Firstly, there is the 'Big Deal' or the 'all-you-can-eat model', where the publisher offers their entire journal portfolio to a consortium for a price equivalent to members' historical subscription holdings, plus an electronic premium, typically in the range of 5–15%. In this arrangement, each member library gains access to the publisher's entire journal portfolio. In the second type of arrangement, member libraries get access to an expanded set of journal content by gaining access to all the journals on a publisher's list that other members of the consortium are already subscribing to. The individual member library's holdings are thus increased to total the sum of all other members' subscriptions to that particular publisher's content. Again, pricing tends to be based on the sum of existing subscriptions, plus an electronic access premium. In most cases, these types of deal are struck directly between consortium and publisher. Senior librarians talking to Key Perspectives stated that they were somewhat surprised that subscription agents have not played a greater role in this process, particularly as the negotiation of consortial licenses is often a complex and protracted undertaking which impacts on the operational resources of both publishers and libraries. Don King's surveys, for example, found that 1 week is generally needed for the initial stages of a consortia license deal, thereafter an average of 80 h per year is spent by the library dealing with publishers, and a further 30 h per year with other libraries, on electronic journal services and related issues. Key Perspectives reported that it has not been unusual for negotiations to last for 1–2 years. The creation of a customised licence for each new deal can slow things down, while securing the agreement of all consortium members can be time-consuming. Deals also may stick on certain clauses—most commonly those relating to inflationary increases over future years, or to archiving and back-file access. However, the process is greatly expedited by the adoption of model licenses which, according to Key Perspectives, are fast becoming the norm. It is partly due to the challenges presented by this process that consortial negotiation has tended to favour the medium and large publisher to date. Not only are the larger publishers able to offer the whole-list deals that provide rapidly increasing collections for libraries, crucially, they also have the resources to dedicate to this intricate and time-consuming sales process. New initiatives are now seeking to redress this imbalance and to help smaller and society publishers to participate. The UK Association of Learned and Professional Society Publishers (ALPSP), is considering the development of a multi-publisher consortium that would help bring clusters of smaller, society-publishers' journal lists to market. PCG, the Publishers Communication Group, a subsidiary of Ingenta, has recently launched Consortialink, a service that similarly makes it possible for small and medium-sized publishers to participate in consortia negotiations via multi-publisher packages and centralized professional sales negotiation. For both library and publisher participants, there is a high degree of financial stability to be gained from consortial deals, at least in the short term. The extended license period of many agreements allows libraries to benefit from predictable budgets, with price-capped inflationary deals agreed in advance. It was reported that where average annual price increases for print holdings had been running at 16–22%, consortial deal annual increases have averaged around 6–7%. For libraries, access to increased content holdings has also resulted in some cost savings in interlibrary lending and document delivery. As well as the additional income and expanded user-bases consortial deals have provided, publishers, too, have welcomed the opportunity to bank on stable revenue streams over a multi-year timeframe. Some have also introduced non-cancellation policies as part of the license terms. For all stakeholders, one of the major benefits of consortial licensing has been rapid and widespread penetration of electronic content, which has in turn stimulated increased usage of that content. Libraries have gained a vastly increased pool of content, users have benefited from access to a broader information resource, authors from greater exposure to their work, while participating publishers have reported dramatic increases in downloaded articles. The availability of this extra electronic content has led to greater use. King's research showed that, as a result of electronic availability and of increased efficiencies in automated searching, the average number of journals now used by scientists has increased to 20 journals per scientist, up from 13 journals 25 years ago. While this is not directly attributable to consortial licences, but to general electronic availability of content, publishers report that journals which were previously not subscribed to by individual libraries experience usage when they are made available to that library's users via a consortial deal, thereby benefiting publishers by increasing visibility of lesser-known journals for readers and authors. Evidence from CiBER's investigation into user behaviour likewise suggests that 'Big Deal' users take advantage of the greater choice on offer. CiBER's case-study of the UK-based publisher Emerald's collection (formerly MCB University Press) analysed the behaviour of Emerald's 'Big Deal' users. The Emerald collection consists of approximately 44 000 abstracts of which 35 000 are available in full text, with an archive available for most journals going back to 1994. Using cookie references and IP identification numbers to distinguish 'Big Deal' users from 'non-Big Deal' users, CiBER found that the former accessed, on average, more journals than non-consortial subscribers. There are, however, drawbacks to the current model. Librarians are concerned that the all-inclusive nature of 'Big Deals' means that low quality, inappropriate or low-usage journals are automatically included in their collections, with little funding left over after 'Big Deal' purchases to finance niche titles from other sources. The effect is to remove a key responsibility of the librarian in the development of a collection of resources matched to the needs of that library's users. Librarians are also concerned that an increased proportion of their budget is spent with a small group of large publishers, which is forcing the cancellation of journals from smaller publisher which, while possibly of relatively smaller readership, may nevertheless be highly relevant to their field. Publishers may also encounter restrictions on revenue growth in the longer term. While consortial licensing has helped them generate additional revenues and boost market share, high market penetration and price-capped annual increases mean that opportunities for future growth are necessarily circumscribed. They will either need to find new markets, or look to improve on the coverage and quality of their current offerings, if they are to achieve business growth over time. There is concern within the library community about the absence of a solution to the problem of archiving. Again, the move from ownership of a physical object to 'leasing' access of electronic content erodes one of a librarian's other traditional roles—the creation of an archive of preserved material. Digital preservation and guarantee of perpetual access will be needed if libraries are to migrate to online-only collections of content in the longer term, but the costs involved are beyond the resources of almost all individual libraries. While publishers also wish to find a solution to this problem, it is doubtful that a private sector solution would be seen as sufficiently robust by the library community and it may be that a public sector approach will be needed to address this issue. But perhaps the greatest problem to emerge from the Institute research is that of future funding. While the rapid take-up of consortial licences was triggered by the availability of extra funds, in many cases provided at national or regional level, or top-sliced from the library's institution, there are strong indications that extra funds will no longer be available when it comes to renewal. While the three studies highlighted some of the many benefits of the consortial site licence to libraries, publishers and users, it is thought highly unlikely by participants from all parts of the scholarly communication chain that things will remain as they are. At the heart of this problem is a financial issue: publishers have expectations of continuing annual increases in their income (even if at a more modest rate than historically) while most library information budgets are fixed or even declining in real terms. The market is evolving. With reduced spending power, consortia members will need, either to make dramatic cuts in other budgets to fund future licenses, or else will need to introduce changes into the current model, to accommodate new market realities. Librarians hope that there can be a return to greater selectivity in the acquisition process, and a move away from the all-or-nothing model. Ideally, they would like to be able to select high-quality journals, and to purchase journals bundled by subject, or in other ways more appropriate to their users' requirements. Both publishers and libraries want to see improvements in usage data. Currently, there are wide variations in the way usage statistics are compiled, making it difficult for libraries to make comparisons and to conduct information audits. Libraries need to elicit more detailed information about how the content they have licensed is being used, while publishers would like to gain an improved understanding of how their products are being accessed. It is hoped that Project COUNTER, a working group setting out to formulate an internationally agreed Code of Practice for usage data, will benchmark standards in this area. Measurement of usage will in turn lead to new ways of measuring value and identifying price points. New purchasing models may emerge that are no longer based on historical subscriptions, but on measurable and relevant levels of actual use, particularly as the environment moves towards more electronic-only content. Rather than allocating the majority of their acquisition budget to bundled collections of pre-selected journals, it is likely that libraries will be attracted to new types of deal that offer core collections of high-quality content, with the option to access less-used titles on an occasional basis. In summary, new and more complex ways will need to be found of measuring both the all-inclusive cost of resources for the library and the value they provide, which can, over time, show the way to a new basis for the bargain between publishers and libraries. Note: the reports referred to in this article are being published as the Proceedings of the Ingenta Institute 2002, and are available from Kate Taylor, Ingenta PLC, 23–38 Hythe Bridge Street, Oxford OX1 2ET. Tel.: 01865 799000, fax: 01865 799111, e-mail: [email protected].
Author: Mark Rowse
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1997759452
