Work

Words Count: How Interest in Stem Cells Has Made the Embryo Available--a Look at the French Law of Bioethics

Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: Is the embryo a ‘person’ or a ‘thing’? This question has haunted French legal thought for 30 years,1 not least because the embryonic entity as such challenges the clear-cut binary legal division between ‘persons’ [personnes] and ‘things’ [choses] inherited from the Napoleonic Civil code.2 Words do count, for it is feared that classifying the embryo as a ‘person’ would—among other things—jeopardise any liberal approach to the abortion issue,3 whereas putting it in the category of ‘things’ does not match the commonly shared intuitive perception in France that embryos and, say, pieces of furniture over which property rights can be exercised, are of different nature. The conundrum has proven to be so puzzling to French law-makers that, although three major statutes on bioethics4 and an even greater number of ones more indirectly related to biomedical issues5 have been enacted by the French Parliament over the past 15 years, the legislator has remained silent on the legal status of the embryo.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2000542293
FWCI: 15.27
Cites:
Cited by: 20
Related to: 10