Comment on “An unexpected pattern of distinct weekly periodicities in climatological variables in Germany” by Dominique Bäumer and Bernhard Vogel
Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: [1] Bäumer and Vogel [2007] (hereinafter referred to as BV07) presented a statistical analysis of sunshine duration, cloud cover, temperature and precipitation data, and found for all these weather elements a significant dependence on the weekday. The analysis was carried out for 12 meteorological stations spread over Germany, for the period 1991–2005. Here data since 1864 (precipitation) or 1901 (sunshine duration) from the Swiss stations Zurich and Lugano are analyzed. In addition, the data from the period 1991–2005 were used in a Monte Carlo analysis to investigate whether pure random effects could generate a weekly cycle as documented by BV07. The following points will be addressed in the data analysis: [2] I. If, as BV07 argue, a human-induced weekly cycle of meteorological variables exists, a similar cycle (probably with a smaller or larger amplitude) should also exist before 1991, as the air composition before 1991 (especially after 1950) was also strongly influenced by human activities, possibly even with higher aerosol numbers. The historical data of Zurich and Lugano were checked for such a cycle. [3] II. If the weekly cycle that BV07 found is due to a new mechanism that had a significant impact only from 1991 onwards, the individual weekdays should show much smaller deviations from the overall mean in the period before 1991 as compared with the period after. It is therefore tested to what extent the deviations for individual weekdays for the period 1991–2005 are statistically significant, using as a basis the overall period 1864–2005 (or 1901–2005 in case of sunshine duration). [4] III. Data on sunshine duration and precipitation amount exhibit important spatial auto-correlation, due to the typical length scale of extra-tropical cyclones and anticyclones and since the main variables that influence convective precipitation (lapse rate, humidity) show a strong spatial auto-correlation. Because the German time series that BV07 analyzed are expected to be spatially auto-correlated, and because also the weather variables measured in Zurich will have spatial autocorrelation with the German data, Lugano was included in this analysis. The weather on the Southern side of the Alpes tends to be poorly correlated with the German weather (between Zurich and Lugano the linear correlation was +0.02 for sunshine duration and +0.27 for precipitation). A further consideration is that Lugano is strongly affected by emissions of pollutants and aerosols from the Po Plateau in Northern Italy (e.g., Milano), so that the mechanisms that BV07 postulate as possible causes for the weekly cycle are also present here. [5] IV. A Monte Carlo analysis was used to test if random effects could explain important deviations that were observed by BV07 and that are also found in this study (for precipitation in Zurich and sunshine duration in Lugano). The Monte Carlo analysis was also used to test whether random effects could explain a weekly cycle as observed by BV07.
Source: Geophysical Research Letters
DOI: 10.1029/2007gl031279
Author: H. J. Hendricks Franssen
Institutions: ETH Zurich, Institute of Environmental Engineering
Language: English
Subfield: Global and Planetary Change
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Climate action
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2003159999
