Work

Survival in Pulmonary Tuberculosis

Year: 1948
Type: article
Abstract: B.C.G.Vaccination SER,-Discussions in print on controversial subjects seldom advance truth and occasionally breed ill feeling.I have stated my views on B.C.G.,1 and-Prof.Wallgren2 and Dr. Malmros' have now stated theirs.I prefer to trust to experiment and experience to reveal the truth.The importance of the subject, however, is so great that I feel it only right to remove the misconceptions about my article under which Prof. Wallgren, at least, seems to be labouring.In the paper that I was asked to read before the International Conference of Physicians last September I did not attempt to assess the value, of B.C.G. vaccination.I made it clear at the beginning that I was deliberately marshalling the evidence against it, and at the end that the conclusions I drew were solely in relation to its probable effect on tuberculosis in this country.I wanted to show that no entirely satisfactory investigations on the efficacy of B.C.G.. had yet been carried out, and that, because of the differing epidemiology of tuberculosis in different countries, conclusions drawn in one part of the world were not necessarily applicable to another.I pleaded for a properly con- trolled investigation into the value of B.C.G. vaccination under English conditions, which, as readers of Prof. Wallgren's article will realize, are very different from those in Sweden.I asked, in fact, for no more than the International Conference in Washington has asked to do in the United States.'If we do not obtain this information now, we shall probably never obtain it, and we shall be forced by public opinion to adopt the use of B.C.G. indiscriminately.If, on the other hand, we do succeed in carrying out an investigation under " scientifi- cally unimpeachable conditions "-and there seems to be some hope of this being realized-I am ready to assure Prof. Wallgren that I shall abide by the tesults.-I am, etc.,
Source: BMJ
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2007128382
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10