Looking "Past Wordsworth and the Rest": Pretexts for Revision in Alice Meynell's "The Shepherdess"
Year: 2000
Type: article
Abstract: Wordsworth's "She Was a Phantom of Delight." 4 But inasmuch as the superficial similarity between "The Shepherdess" and such precursory texts dissembles Meynell's departure from the conceptual values that inform her predecessors' work, the poem vacillates ambiguously between overt collusion with and covert criticism of conventional representations of femininity.In short, "The Shepherdess" illuminates the peculiar tensions generated by a turn-of-the-century poet's effort to turn conservative aesthetic practices to modern feminist use.Sadly, despite the challenges posed in her writing, Meynell has herself all but disappeared into the "dark and indescribed" spaces of literary history.Except for reflections prompted by her death in 1922 and the centenary of her birth in 1947, critical notice has been rare. 5 During the early twentieth century, she nonetheless enjoyed the praise, sometimes fulsome, of a select readership sympathetic to her as a woman and a Roman Catholic.Of her lyrics, the most popular was "The Shepherdess."In fact, the poem was so popular that an assistant in a London bookstore, discovering that her client was the poet's husband, quoted the first line and declared, "Ten thousand shop girls in England bless Alice Meynell for having written that." 6No less fervid in his admiration, Rev. William C. Hall placed "the delicate precision of diction and the haunting syllables or the rarely woven words of the lyric" above anything written by Christina Rossetti or Elizabeth Barrett Browning, thus putting Meynell herself firmly in the pantheon of Victorian women poets. 7But other critics, while commending the "fastidious technique" responsible for such formal perfection, found "The Shepherdess" "over-precious." 8Indeed, some feared its popularity as an anthology piece would damage Meynell's reputation as a modern poet.Agnes Repplier, for example, "regretted that the poem by which this felicitous writer bids fair to be best remembered is the familiar and perpetually quoted 'Shepherdess.'" 9Citing "Parentage" and "Saint Catherine of Siena," she applauded instead those lyrics in which the poet "brought every subject up to date" and addressed such issues as pacifism and suffragism (p.723).Yet "The Shepherdess," by modernizing the lady of the lyrics, also brings its "subject up to date" and so negotiates unnoticed a divide between received form and reformed content.Recently, critics such as Angela Leighton and John S. Anson have reiterated Repplier's complaint.For Leighton, Meynell is "remembered only for one, and that probably the worst, of all her poems: 'The Shepherdess.'" 10 By way of correction, she dismisses the poem's "mincing sickliness" (p.263) in favor of the "unobtrusively suggestive scepticism" of those "unsentimental poems about mothers and children" (p.257).Anson, on the other hand, asserts that "The Shepherdess" not only illustrates the limitations that account for Meynell's current status as "an unread poet," but sincerely emu-
Source: Victorian poetry
DOI: 10.1353/vp.2000.0011
Author: Sharon Smulders
Language: English
Subfield: Literature and Literary Theory
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2043903281
