Work

Charge State Evolution in the Solar Wind. Iii. Model Comparison With Observations

Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: We test three theoretical models of the fast solar wind with a set of remote sensing observations and in-situ measurements taken during the minimum of solar cycle 23. First, the model electron density and temperature are compared to SOHO /SUMER spectroscopic measurements. Second, the model electron density, temperature, and wind speed are used to predict the charge state evolution of the wind plasma from the source regions to the freeze-in point. Frozen-in charge states are compared with Ulysses /SWICS measurements at 1 AU, while charge states close to the Sun are combined with the CHIANTI spectral code to calculate the intensities of selected spectral lines, to be compared with SOHO /SUMER observations in the north polar coronal hole. We find that none of the theoretical models are able to completely reproduce all observations; namely, all of them underestimate the charge state distribution of the solar wind everywhere, although the levels of disagreement vary from model to model. We discuss possible causes of the disagreement, namely, uncertainties in the calculation of the charge state evolution and of line intensities, in the atomic data, and in the assumptions on the wind plasma conditions. Last, we discuss the scenario where the wind is accelerated from a region located in the solar corona rather than in the chromosphere as assumed in the three theoretical models, and find that a wind originating from the corona is in much closer agreement with observations.
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
Awards: THE SOLAR WIND PLAYS A FUNDAMENTAL ROLE IN SHAPING THE HELIOSPHERE AND GOVERNING THE INTERACTIONS IN THE NEAR EARTH SPACE ENVIRONMENT AND ATMOSPHERE AND IT ULTIMATELY DRIVES THE CONDITIONS IN THE REGION OF INTERPLANETARY SPACE THAT WILL BE EXPLORED BY HUMANS. DESPITE ITS IMPORTANCE AND ALL THE EFFORTS AIMED AT STUDYING IT THERE ARE STILL MANY UNANSWERED QUESTIONS REGARDING THE ORIGIN ACCELERATION AND EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR WIND. TWO FUNDAMENTAL OPEN QUESTIONS IN SOLAR WIND SCIENCE ARE: 1) WHERE DOES THE SOLAR WIND PLASMA COME FROM I.E. FROM WHAT TYPE OF PLASMA STRUCTURES AND FROM WHAT REGIONS IN THE SOLAR ATMOSPHERE AND 2) HOW ISTHE SOLAR WIND HEATED AND ACCELERATED? WE PROPOSE TO DIRECTLY AND QUANTITATIVELY COMBINE HIGH-RESOLUTION OBSERVATIONS OF THE EUV EMISSION OF SOLAR CORONAL PLASMAS WITH IN-SITU PLASMA OBSERVATIONS OBTAINED DURING QUADRATURE BETWEEN ULYSSES SOHO AND HINODE TO ACHIEVE THREE GOALS: 1) TO DETERMINE THE SOURCE REGIONS OF THE FAST AND SLOW SOLAR WIND; 2) TO PROVIDE AN EMPIRICAL DETERMINATION OF WIND PLASMA PARAMETERS AND HEATING; AND 3) TO DEVELOP A PREDICTIVE TOOL THAT USES EMPIRICAL OR MODEL WIND TEMPERATURE DENSITY AND VELOCITY AS A FUNCTION OF DISTANCE FROM THE SUN TO PRODUCE DETAILED QUANTITATIVE PREDICTIONS OF THE EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR WIND CHARGE STATE COMPOSITION. PREDICTED CHARGE STATES WILL BE USED TO DETERMINE BOTH THE FINAL FROZEN-IN CHARGE STATES IN THE SOLAR WIND AND THE X-RAY EUV AND UV EMISSION OF THE WIND SOURCE REGIONS IN THE INNER CORONA. THESE GOALS WILL BE ACHIEVED THROUGH A UNIQUE COMBINATION OF SPECTROSCOPIC AND IN SITU TECHNIQUES. WE WILL MEASURE THE PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF THE SOLAR WIND SOURCE REGIONS USING HIGH-RESOLUTION SPECTRA FROM SOHO AND HINODE. WE WILL USE THE SPECTROSCOPIC MEASUREMENTS OF PLASMA PARAMETERS AS INPUT TO THE IONCOMPOSITION MODEL TOGETHER WITH AN ASSUMED PLASMA VELOCITY FUNCTION TO PREDICT ION COMPOSITION AS A FUNCTION OF DISTANCE FROM THE WIND SOURCE REGION. THE ION COMPOSITION WILL BE USED TO 1) COMPARE FROZEN-IN CHARGE STATES WITH ULYSSES MEASUREMENTS AT ONE END OF THE SOLAR WIND TRAJECTORY AND 2) CALCULATE LINE INTENSITIES AND NARROW-BAND IMAGES IN THE INNERMOST REGIONS OF THE SOLAR CORONA TO BE COMPARED WITH OBSERVATIONS FROM THE SPECTROMETERS ON BOARD SOHO AND HINODE AT THE OTHER END OF THE WIND TRAJECTORY. THIS DOUBLE COMPARISON WILL ALLOW US TO: 1) TEST THE ACCURACY OF THE IONIZATION MODEL'S PREDICTION 2) DIRECTLY TEST THE WIND PLASMA PARAMETERS (DENSITY TEMPERATURE AND VELOCITY) USED AS INPUT TO THE IONIZATION MODEL; AND 3) DEVELOP AN EMPIRICAL MODEL OF THE PLASMA VELOCITY ACCELERATION AND THERMAL HISTORY BELOW 1.5 SOLAR RADII. THE RESULTS OF THIS PROPOSED WORK WILL BE TWOFOLD. FIRST WE WILL PROVIDE THE COMMUNITY WITH A NEW POWERFUL TOOL TO PREDICT THE EVOLUTION OF ION CHARGE STATES IN THE SOLAR WIND AS WELL AS A NEW METHODOLOGY TO STUDY THE SOLAR WIND QUANTITATIVELY MATCHING TWO COMPLETELY DIFFERENT TYPES OF OBSERVATIONS: REMOTE-SENSING OBSERVATIONS AND IN-SITUION COMPOSITION MEASUREMENT. SECOND THE APPLICATION OF THIS NEW METHODOLOGY TO EXISTING IN SITU AND REMOTE SENSING OBSERVATIONS WILL RESULT IN A) AN ACCURATE EMPIRICAL DESCRIPTION OF THE WIND HEATING AND ACCELERATION; AND B) THE IDENTIFICATION OF THE WIND SOURCE REGIONS. RESULTS FROM THE PROPOSED INVESTIGATIONS WILL PROVIDE CRITICAL INPUT TO THEORETICAL MODELS OF SOLAR WIND HEATING AND ACCELERATION. THE PROPOSED INVESTIGATION WILL PAVE THE WAY TO A NEW METHOD TO STUDY EXISTING DATA FROM NASA MISSIONS AND INSTRUMENTS ENHANCING THEIR SCIENTIFIC RETURN. THE GOALS OF THE PROPOSED INVESTIGATION ARE OF DIRECT FUNDAMENTAL IMPORTANCE TO NASA'S STRATEGIC GOAL 2.2("UNDERSTAND THE SUN AND ITS INTERACTIONS WITH EARTH AND THE SOLAR SYSTEM") AND ARE IN LINE WITH THE GOALS OF ALL THE NASA MISSIONS AND INSTRUMENTS INVOLVED IN THE PROPOSED WORK: ULYSSES HINODE AND SOHO., MO & DA OF THE ADVANCE COMPOSITION EXPLORER MISSION PHASE 2DATA AN ALYSIS ACTIVITIES BY CALTECH'S, THE SLOW WIND IS A SIZEABLE COMPONENT OF THE SOLAR WIND AND PLAYS A FUNDAMENTAL ROLE IN SHAPING THE INTERPLANETARY ENVIRONMENT. YET THE SLOW WIND HA, QUANTITATIVE VALIDATION AND ASSESSMENTS OF SOLAR/HELIOSPHERIC 3D MODELING CODES USING EMPIRICAL DATA FROM REMOTE-SENSING AND IN SITU MEASUREMENTSWE, THIS PROPOSAL IS FOCUSED ON TWO FUNDAMENTAL CHALLENGES THAT HAVE PLAGUED OUR UNDERSTANDING OF THE ORIGIN OF THE SLOW SOLAR WIND: 1) THE SLOW SOLAR WI, SHINE: Differential Emission Measure Determination in Three-Dimension (3D) Using Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) Data
OpenAlex ID: W2043968417
FWCI: 0.817
Cites: 57
Cited by: 29
Related to: 10