How far will the courts go in ensuring the right to a basic education
Year: 2012
Type: article
Abstract: IntroductionGazing into the crystal ball of socio-economic rights jurisprudence in 1998, former Chief Justice Ismael Mahomed speculated about a difficulty the courts may face in adjudicating socio-economic rights.The difficulty that he identified was that enforcement of the relevant right may not only involve a negative protection against the violation of a particular right, but also the duty to deliver that right.A 1 court order of this nature might compel the legislature to reorganise their priorities or budgets in a manner that affects the rights of others.He selected a hypothetical example in the field of education law.An order, for exam ple, that prim ary education at state expense be accorded to all children under the age of sixteen, m ight com pel the state to prioritise that right over the right to deliver nutrition to dying infants in hospitals who are entitled to prim ary health care.The objection to that kind of constitutional objectivism is that it m ight give to a court, which does not have the burden of political accountability, the power to m ake orders in areas in which it has no greater expertise than the legislature or the executive and that it invades the guarantee inherent in the separation of powers upon which a legitim ate constitutional democracy is prem ised.President Jacob Zuma alluded to the separation of powers in his address to the Access to Justice Conference organised by the Office of the Chief Justice in July 2011.He stated that there 'is a need to distinguish the areas of responsibility 2
Author: Ann Skelton
Institution: University of Pretoria
Language: English
Topic: Legal Issues in South Africa
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W204798524
