Year: 1987
Type: article
Abstract: In this paper I ask what it is for one's performance of some locutionary action to count-as one's performance of some illocutionary action, After looking at the so-called institutional analysis and finding it unsatisfactory, I offer a normative analysis: To perform an illocutionary action is to acquire a certain normative standing, or status.I go on to ask how such acquisition comes about by way of making sounds or inscribing marks.If my analysis is correct, it follows that only those creatures who can acquire rights and responsibilities can speak~that is, perform illocutionary actions.It is my contention that animals cannot.Why is it that men speak and animals don't?What does it entail to be a speaking creature, that is, a creature who names things and utters sentences about things which other similar creatures understaad and misunderstand?Why is it that every normal man on earth speaks, that is, can utter an unlimited number of sentences in a complex language, and that not one single beast has ever uttered a word?...Why is there such a qualitative gap between nonspeaking animals and speaking man, when there is no other such gap in nature?... Is it possible that a theory of man is nothing more or less than a theory of the speaking creature?... Instead of marking him down at the outset as besouIed creature or responding organism, why not look at him as he is, not even as Homo sapiens (because attributing sapience already begs the question), but as Homo loquens, man the talker, or Homo ~)'mbolificus, man the symbolmonger?Instead of starting out with such large, vexing subjects as soul, mind, ideas, consciousness, why not set forth with language, which no one denies, and see how far it takes us toward the rest?Instead of behaviorists trying to explain language by stimulus-response theory, why not try to account for behaviorists by a larger theory of language ... ?'The sounds are so innocuous, and the linguistic significance often so vast.
Source: Faith and Philosophy
Authors: Nicholas Wolterstorff, The Society of Christian Philosophers
Language: English
Subfield: Language and Linguistics
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2083123719
