Work

"Šoppamise" sooline representatsioon

Year: 2004
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The goal of the MA thesis was to describe and analyze the gender dimension of a \ncertain form of consumption called “šoppamine” (to shop and shopping in English). \nBeing part of a larger research initiative that focuses on cultural practices \ncharacterizing our society these days (Margit Keller’s Ph.D thesis, Raili Roo’s and \nMerilin Seepter’s BA thesis’s), this thesis adds an intriguing angle to the existing \nresearch material and offers additional opportunities for understanding and critically \nanalyzing Estonian consumer culture. \n \nIn addition to the research carried out at Tartu University, different theories focusing \non consumer society and shopping practices as well as theories on gender form the \ntheoretical basis of the current thesis. \n \nThe empirical analysis of the thesis is based on consumer interviews and media texts. \n70 ad hoc as well as in-depth oral interviews were carried out with consumers in \nTallinn and Tartu. In addition to those, 100 print media texts published in years 2002 – \n2004 and including the word “šoppamine” or some of its forms are analyzed to get an \noverview of the concept’s media representations and to compare those to consumers’ \nopinions. Both quantitative and qualitative research methods were combined in the \nresearch, the main theories used were the ones of Miles and Huberman (1994) and \nNorman Fairclough (1995). \n \nThe two general hypotheses of the thesis were the following: First, that “šoppamine” is \nconsidered to be a feminine practice and connected far more with women than men \nboth in media texts’ representations as well as in consumers’ opinions. Secondly, that \nmedia represents more homogeneous picture when it comes to the gender aspect of \n“šoppamine” while consumers themselves share more heterogeneous point of views \nand do not see the practice only as a feminine one. \n \nThe following research questions were formed: 1) how do our consumers see and \nunderstand the gender aspect of the discourse of “šoppamine”?; 2) how is “šoppamine” \nand its gender aspect represented in Estonian print media channels?; 2.1) are women more connected with “šoppamine” than men?; 2.2) what are the explicit and implicit \nconnections dominating between “šoppamine” and gender?; 3) why does the \nrepresentation and (re)production of “šoppamine” and its gender aspect appear as it \ndoes? \n \nSummarizing the results of the research one can conclude that both hypotheses were \nverified – the practice called “šoppamine” really is primarily connected with women \nmore than men both in media as well in people’s minds. But among consumers also an \nalternative, “equal” mindset is seen reflecting an opinion that both sexes actually do \n“shop”. Such a representation is not visible in media texts. \n \nAnalyzing the both texts one found out that consumers have rather ambivalent \nevaluations towards “šoppamine” – both men and women criticize the practice while \nthe ones positively minded are mostly women. The same tendency can be seen in \nmedia – opinions and evaluations vary from very positive, encouraging and even \nheroic discourse to critical and condemnatory. Tabloid media is logically more positive \ntowards “šoppamine” while daily and weekly papers focused on “harder” news reflect \nmore critical views. \n \nAs the thesis focuses on gender aspect, the ideas about the content and purposes of \n“šoppamine” are important. Based on research one can claim that those ideas differ \nwhen comparing consumers and media representations. Both parties agree the practice \nincludes hedonistic, pleasurable and fun sides; also that it is mostly oriented to \neverything that’s external. People say “šoppama” when they buy clothes or shoes but \nthey do not say it when buying food for example. The abovementioned difference \nbetween media and consumers’ views appears when interpreting “šoppamine” as an \nactivity focused to mainly watching (process-oriented) or mainly buying (result- \noriented). In media, the latter dominates while consumers interpret “šoppamine” \nmainly as walking-watching-choosing and after that maybe buying. That kind of \nconcept is more about spending time and less about spending money; different from \nthe one that media represents - in media “šoppamine” is often presented via buying (a \nlot). In connection to that it also arises topics about exaggeration and extremes when it \ncomes to the practice. Dependency, craziness, emotionality and lose of control are \nsome of the keywords that often “pop up” in media texts in connection with “šoppamine” and women. But the consumers interviewed like to describe themselves \nas much more reasonable and thrifty than the media image. The self-image of critical \nand rational, somewhat “enlightened” consumer is very usual when it comes to men; \nby important others women are more connected with emotions, impulses, also \ncredulity and influenceability. Women themselves more or less agree with those rather \nstereotypical opinions but still do not think that extreme, maniac forms of “šoppamine” \nare of a real danger for them or for Estonian society in general. \n \nSummarizing the social aspect of “šoppamine” one can say that the practice is mostly \ndirected to others. Men almost always like to go shopping with others, families or \nfriends while women sometimes prefer to do it alone, “taking their own time and doing \ntheir own things”. That marks a procreative aspect of “šoppamine” specially important \nfor female consumers. \n \nOne can conclude that “šoppamine” in modern Estonian consumer society no doubt is \na feminine practice although it always doesn’t have to be a practice carried out by \nwomen – many “new age” men may do it as well as they are not afraid of feminine \nconnotations that might arise. And even if there are widespread views about \n“šoppamine” as hedonistic, egoistic and trivial activity, the practice still offers several \nresources for women as well as men to carry out their individual and social life \nprojects.
Author: Katrin Rahu
Institution: University of Tartu
Language: Estonian
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2138501422
Cites: 14
Cited by: 5
Related to: 10