Work

Increasing Photosynthetic Carbon Assimilation in C3 Plants to Improve Crop Yield: Current and Future Strategies

Year: 2010
Type: review
Abstract: The realization that crop yields are reaching a plateau, while population increases continue at pace, has placed manipulation of photosynthesis in a central position to achieve increases in yield. Increasing flux through the C3 cycle will be a major focus of this effort. Through application of new technologies together with novel modeling approaches, increased yield through improved photosynthetic carbon fixation should be an attainable goal in the near to mid term. This Update article reviews the past approaches and successes in this area. An outline of some of the known targets for future work is given, and approaches to identify novel targets for exploitation are outlined. Improving crop yield to meet the demands of an increasing world population for food and fuel is a central challenge for plant biology (Edgerton, 2009). This goal must be achieved in a sustainable manner (i.e. with minimal agricultural inputs and environmental impacts) in the face of elevated levels of CO2 and more extreme conditions of water availability and temperature. Agricultural yields have generally kept pace with demand in the recent past as a result of the gains made through breeding programs and farming practice, but crops yields are now reaching a plateau. One fundamental component of plant productivity that has not been used to select for increased yield is photosynthesis. There is now the opportunity to exploit our extensive knowledge of this fundamental process for the benefit of humankind (von Caemmerer and Evans, 2010; Zhu et al., 2010a). In the plant kingdom, there are three pathways of photosynthetic, atmospheric CO2 fixation. However, the vast majority of plant species fix atmospheric CO2 using the enzyme Rubisco in the Calvin-Benson cycle. The first stable product of this cycle is a three-carbon compound, phosphoglycerate (3-PGA), and for this reason this process is referred to as the C3 cycle. Plants utilizing this pathway are often referred to as C3 species. A major problem with the C3 cycle is the enzyme Rubisco. This is because Rubisco is not only an inefficient enzyme with a low turnover number, but it also catalyzes two competing reactions: carboxylation and oxygenation (Portis and Parry, 2007). The oxygenation reaction directs the flow of carbon through the photorespiratory pathway (Fig. 1), and this can result in losses of between 25% and 30% of the carbon fixed. Environmental variables, such as high temperature and drought, can result in an increase in the oxygenase reaction. Therefore, reducing the Rubisco oxygenase reaction has the potential to increase carbon assimilation significantly and would represent a step change in photosynthesis (up to 100% depending on temperature; Long et al., 2006). The C3 cycle. The carboxylation reaction catalyzed by Rubisco fixes CO2 into the acceptor molecule RuBP, forming 3-PGA. The reductive phase of the cycle follows with two reactions catalyzed by 3-PGA kinase (PGK) and GAPDH, producing G-3-P. The G-3-P enters the regenerative phase catalyzed by aldolase (Ald) and either FBPase or SBPase, producing Fru-6-P (F-6-P) and sedoheptulose-7-P (S-7-P). Fru-6-P and sedoheptulose-7-P are then utilized in reactions catalyzed by TK, R-5-P isomerase (RPI), and ribulose-5-P (Ru-5-P) epimerase (RPE), producing Ru-5-P. The final step converts Ru-5-P to RuBP, catalyzed by PRK. The oxygenation reaction of Rubisco fixes O2 into the acceptor molecule RuBP, forming PGA and 2-phosphoglycolate (2PG), and the process of photorespiration (shown in red) releases CO2 and PGA. The five export points from the pathway are shown with blue arrows. Two metabolic pathways have evolved to overcome this, the C4 (the first stable compound synthesized is a C4 acid, oxaloacetate) and crassulacean acid metabolism pathways. Both the C4 and crassulacean acid metabolism pathways are additional to the C3 cycle and increase the supply of CO2 to Rubisco, thereby reducing the oxygenation reaction and flux to the photorespiratory pathway. This review will focus on progress and future prospects to improve the C3 cycle. The C3 cycle is the primary pathway of carbon assimilation in the majority of photosynthetic organisms. It is the single largest flux of organic carbon in the biosphere and assimilates about 100 billion tons of carbon a year (15% of the carbon in the atmosphere). Understanding the responses of the Calvin cycle to altered demands for photosynthate within the plant and to external environmental conditions is essential for attempts to increase yield and to redirect carbon into important products. The C3 cycle utilizes the products of the light reactions of photosynthesis, ATP and NADPH, to fix atmospheric CO2 into carbon skeletons that are used to fuel the rest of plant metabolism (Fig. 1; Stitt et al., 2010). The C3 cycle is initiated by the enzyme Rubisco that catalyzes the carboxylation of the CO2 acceptor molecule ribulose-1,5-bisP (RuBP). 3-PGA formed by this reaction is used to form the triose phosphates glyceraldehyde phosphate (G-3-P) and dihydroxyacetone phosphate via two reactions that consume ATP and NADPH. The regenerative phase of the cycle involves a series of reactions that convert triose phosphates into the CO2 acceptor molecule RuBP (Fig. 1). Carbon compounds produced in this cycle are essential for growth and development of the plant (Raines and Paul, 2006; Smith and Stitt, 2007). While the majority (five-sixths) of the triose phosphate produced in the Calvin cycle remain within the cycle to regenerate RuBP, one-sixth of the carbon exits the cycle for biosynthesis of a range of compounds. Triose and hexose phosphates are used to synthesize Suc and starch, and erythrose-4-P (E-4-P) goes directly to the shikimate pathway for the biosynthesis of amino acids and lignin, G-3-P to the isoprenoid pathway, and Rib-5-P (R-5-P) for nucleotide, thiamine metabolism, and cell wall biosynthesis (Fig. 1). Clearly, the Calvin cycle occupies a central position in carbon metabolism. Manipulation of this pathway has the potential to increase yield and production of carbon for the synthesis of products made in secondary metabolic pathways. It has been known for some time that a large proportion of the limitation to carbon assimilation in plants using the C3 cycle is due to the catalytic properties of the enzyme Rubisco (Portis and Parry, 2007). During the 1990s, metabolic control analysis was used to explore the possibility that enzymes other than Rubisco may also have a role in determining rates of carbon flux through the C3 cycle (Stitt and Schulze, 1994; Raines, 2003). To undertake metabolic control analysis of a pathway, it is necessary to be able to reduce specifically the amount of an individual enzyme in that pathway; the effect of this reduction on flux can then be compared to the control. The flux control coefficient can vary from 0, for an enzyme that makes no contribution to control, to 1, for an enzyme that exerts total control. One fundamental difference between this approach and that based on the kinetics of individual enzymes is that metabolic control analysis allows for all enzymes in a pathway to share control of flux in that pathway. The flux control value for any single enzyme is not a constant and can change depending on the conditions under which the analysis was carried out. Transgenic plants with reductions in Rubisco protein levels produced using an antisense construct were used to assess the relative contribution that Rubisco imposed on carbon flux. This approach has demonstrated clearly that the limitation imposed by Rubisco on C3 carbon fixation is greatest in high light and temperature conditions (Stitt and Schulze, 1994). In contrast, as expected, this is reduced in plants grown in elevated CO2 (Masle et al., 1993). Importantly, these transgenic studies also showed that Rubisco does not limit the C3 cycle in all conditions and that enzymes of the regenerative phase of the cycle also play a role in determining the rate of photosynthesis (Raines, 2003, 2006; Stitt et al., 2010). Regeneration of the CO2 acceptor molecule RuBP involves eight enzymes (Fig. 1). To identify enzymes that have significant control over carbon flux through the Calvin cycle, antisense plants with reduced levels of individual enzymes were created and analyzed (Stitt and Schulze, 1994; Raines, 2003). Under many conditions, reductions in the activities of enzymes catalyzing highly regulated, effectively irreversible reactions, glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH), Fru bisphosphatase (FBPase), and phosphoribulokinase (PRK), had little impact on carbon assimilation (for review, see Raines, 2003; Stitt et al., 2010). In contrast, small reductions in the enzyme sedoheptulose-1,7-bisphosphatase (SBPase) resulted in a decrease in CO2 fixation and growth, identifying this enzyme as a major control point in the C3 cycle. The relative importance of SBPase in determining flux through this cycle varied with development and environmental conditions, confirming that no one enzyme limits the C3 cycle under all conditions (Harrison et al., 1998, 2001; Olçer et al., 2001). Somewhat surprisingly carbon flux through the C3 cycle was also reduced in plants with relatively small reductions in the activity of either transketolase (TK) or aldolase, enzymes that are not highly regulated and operate close to equilibrium (Haake et al., 1998, 1999; Henkes et al., 2001). This was unexpected, as it was thought that enzymes that were highly regulated would be most important in determining the rate of carbon flow through the cycle. These analyses of the antisense C3 cycle plants identified enzymes other than Rubisco that can limit CO2 fixation. This work also indicated that it may be possible to increase photosynthetic carbon fixation and growth by increasing the levels of SBPase or, to a lesser extent, TK. Experiments exploring this hypothesis are described below. Three approaches to improve the C3 cycle have targeted Rubisco-associated bottlenecks. Expression of the cyanobacterial ictB protein in higher plants to reduce the oxygenation reaction of Rubisco resulted in the production of transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) with higher photosynthetic rates under limiting, but not saturating, CO2 levels. Similar results were obtained in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) plants expressing the ictB from Anabaena PCC7120; in low humidity conditions, the growth of transgenic Arabidopsis plants was faster and the final dry weight was higher than that of wild-type plants (Lieman-Hurwitz et al., 2003). A second approach introduced the enzymes of the bacterial glycolate pathway into plants, creating a photorespiratory bypass in the chloroplast (Peterhansel and Maurino, 2011). In Arabidopsis, this resulted in reduced photorespiration and increased CO2 assimilation and biomass yield (Kebeish et al., 2007; Leegood, 2007). These two strategies for overcoming the oxygenase reaction of Rubisco offer more immediate alternatives to improve crop photosynthesis in the near future, compared to the more ambitious CO2-concentrating strategies described below in the future approaches section. The activation state of Rubisco is dependent on the enzyme Rubisco activase, which at temperatures above 30°C has been shown to be unstable in vitro. This led to the suggestion that Rubisco activase is responsible for the reversible temperature-sensitive reduction in the activation state of Rubisco, leading to inhibition of photosynthesis when plants are subjected to mild heat stress (Salvucci and Crafts-Brandner, 2004). The introduction of a thermostable version of the Rubisco activase enzyme into an Arabidopsis activase deletion mutant resulted in transgenic lines with higher photosynthetic rates and increased biomass and seed yield when compared with control plants expressing the wild-type activase (Kurek et al., 2007). All three of these approaches have demonstrated the potential to stimulate photosynthesis and growth in model species, and the next step will be to test this in crop plants in natural environments. Transgenic antisense work described above identified SBPase, plastid aldolase, and TK as enzymes that might be targets for improving C3 cycle flux. Indeed, overexpression of either a bifunctional SBPase/FBPase or plant SBPase in tobacco plants resulted in increased photosynthetic CO2 fixation and growth (Miyagawa et al., 2001; Lefebvre et al., 2005). Analysis of CO2 response curves revealed that this increase in photosynthesis could be attributed to an increase in the capacity to regenerate the CO2 acceptor molecule RuBP. Measurements of ambient photosynthesis over the daily cycle revealed an increase in photosynthetic rates of between 6% and 12%. Of particular interest for crop improvement is that these plants also displayed an increase in leaf area and biomass of up to 30%. Young seedlings (4/5 leaves) with increased SBPase activity were shown to have an increase in leaf area compared to wild-type plants. Chlorophyll fluorescence imaging of these young plants revealed a higher photosynthetic capacity at the whole plant level. These plants also showed an increased growth rate during the early phase of development (Lefebvre et al., 2005). This result is of significance in an agricultural context as rapid, early seedling establishment is known to contribute to yield increases at maturity. In contrast to the results with tobacco, increasing SBPase activity in rice (Oryza sativa) did not lead to increases in photosynthesis or growth. However, if the plants were subjected to heat or salt stress conditions, photosynthesis rates in the transgenic plants with increased SBPase plant were higher than in wild-type controls (Feng et al., 2007a, 2007b). The rice studies highlight the fact that increasing photosynthesis and yield by manipulation of SBPase is likely to be dependent not only on species but also growth conditions. Plastid TK was also identified as a potential target to increase the regenerative capacity of the C3 cycle (Henkes et al., 2001). To explore this possibility, transgenic plants have been produced overexpressing TK, either on its own or together with overexpression of SBPase. Analysis of these transgenic plants has shown that photosynthetic rates were similar to wild type but that the plants have reduced growth and display a chlorotic phenotype. The basis of this phenotype has not been fully resolved, but preliminary analysis would suggest that increasing TK activity has perturbed the balance of export of carbon from the C3 cycle (M. Khozaei, S.C. Lefebvre, T. Lawson, and C.A. Raines, unpublished data). This is in keeping with data from antisense studies that revealed a reduction in carbon flow from the C3 cycle to the shikimate pathway that correlated with reductions in TK activity (Henkes et al., 2001). This work highlights the need for modeling approaches that not only allow identification of potential targets for improving CO2 assimilation but that will also allow flux from the C3 cycle to be determined. This is discussed in the modeling section below. The oxygenase reaction of Rubisco and subsequent photorespiratory pathway are clear targets for improvement of the C3 cycle (Whitney et al., 2011). Over the last 20 years, considerable effort has been focused on reengineering the Rubisco protein, using to increase the relative to the oxygenase reaction. However, this approach has to an improved Rubisco et al., 2007). it has been shown that it is possible to form an Rubisco in using large with the and ATP et al., 2010). This work the for in analysis of and has the potential to allow for in the Rubisco catalytic of A new opportunity has also from of Rubisco catalytic properties that has revealed in the and temperature response of Rubisco from natural in the et al., 2005). The in the properties would that Rubisco from these species into crop plants could increase the rate of CO2 The recent of the of Rubisco large and small as a single protein in the chloroplast that into an the opportunity to of Rubisco as a to improve the C3 cycle (Whitney and 2007; et al., 2009). CO2-concentrating have been in all plant in species, and in the These the possibility to exploit that have evolved in these to improve C3 plants and et al., 2011). To the potential of these strategies will likely be in the it is essential to the now to the as a for future C4 photosynthesis to C3 species is one to reduce C3 plants to C4 metabolism will be a challenge as not only is there a for additional metabolism but there are also in et al., et al., Zhu et al., at the basis of the and the determining the and the of of the enzymes is under and 2010). this has not led to any major the of new and technologies together with a large for future in this area. The a in the cell that and fixes as a et al., 2006; and 2007; et al., some a the that may to CO2 at Rubisco and 2007). Both of these that could be to higher plants to reduce photorespiration and increase water and However, it is likely that the from either of these of into higher plants will be a of and that the of the remain to be these approaches are likely to be only in the term. However, the and more than the of Rubisco. It might be more attainable in the to exploit the CO2 in these to CO2 levels in C3 plants and thereby have a effect on CO2 assimilation by Rubisco et al., 2011). of of Carbon antisense studies described above revealed enzymes in the C3 cycle as targets for it would be to potential manipulation in this It is attainable to select targets that may impact to improve the cycle. In that significant can be made in a time it will be essential to have a model that is A model of photosynthetic carbon metabolism has been and its in with an indicated that the of between enzymes of carbon metabolism is the amount of is not et al., 2007). An in enzymes of the photorespiratory pathway, and an in SBPase, and plastid aldolase enzymes were This that the rate of photosynthesis in C3 plants could be increased significantly by of the of these enzymes in carbon and The from this modeling can be using transgenic using a model plant Importantly, the results from this work have the potential to clear strategies for improvement of photosynthesis in a time of to A of the C3 cycle is the control of flux from the cycle to the pathways of starch, and (Fig. 1). analysis of the of starch, and shikimate pathways have been there is no model that can the the relative flux to these pathways during in response to stress or availability of This of knowledge on the to exploit the potential for manipulation of the cycle for the synthesis of high value such as plant and compounds that are products of the shikimate and isoprenoid pathways of the C3 cycle. and of a Carbon the majority of photosynthetic fix atmospheric CO2 through the C3 cycle, in there are five other CO2 fixation pathways that are in the that have and metabolism similar to and more with the et al., 2010). of these either Rubisco or as the carboxylation a of metabolism that has evolved in response to a range of environmental This the possibility of a of modeling together with to construct novel CO2 fixation pathways that may be more than the C3 cycle. In this approach may offer a to the problem of Rubisco to plant for introduction of the C4 pathway. a modeling approach that enzymes known to a of carbon fixation pathways were identified et al., 2010). This showed that some of these pathways may be more than the C3 cycle. all of the pathways to be to faster than the C3 cycle the enzyme which is the enzyme in C4 species, and not any of the enzymes in the These pathways also share a of reactions and have been the pathways (Fig. the produced could be to G-3-P by enzymes from there is a to synthesize hexose and to supply the essential carbon compounds for growth and development of the a pathway was to be into it may to a Calvin cycle, creating carbon To the pathway, it would also be necessary to some of the G-3-P to regenerate the for CO2 assimilation (Fig. The to such large in the CO2 in higher plants using biology will be metabolism based on the modeling of et a novel and approach that carbon carbon fixation pathway. This pathway the enzyme to fix atmospheric CO2 into and the only product of this cycle is phosphate The in blue are for carbon that may be need to be to the cycle in to with a C3 cycle to the for biosynthesis of shikimate Suc and from et There is considerable in photosynthetic rates leaf area between C3 species. This is an and has potential to identify natural that have evolved to allow plants to in environments. analysis of plants from using in photosynthesis has the potential to identify novel targets for manipulation in crop plants. of photosynthetic capacity also in the species when grown under environmental this can result in in and and is In some plant species are able to photosynthetic capacity in fully a A recent revealed that and are and that may have a role in increasing the of plants in natural et al., 2010). However, most studies focus on plants grown in constant conditions or a to conditions, low to high There have been studies plants have been to conditions. of the that are by plants during environmental can novel targets for improving crop yield. This is that many crop species any range to to this et al., 2009). little about is the relative importance of in determining carbon flux in the C3 cycle. It has been known for that a of enzymes of the C3 cycle, SBPase, and GAPDH, are subjected to light activation via the Importantly, there is a in this response when plants a to light in a of in photosynthetic rates reaching a and 1994; et al., 1994). It has also been shown that the enzymes and are to in response to in light by a small protein, together with et al., et al., 2009). These are to the rate of carbon fixation with the availability of from the light However, the relative importance of this in determining photosynthetic capacity is but may be important in the response of plants with conditions. the to which this between species is also relatively Manipulation of the C3 cycle an opportunity to increase photosynthesis and yield. A of clear targets have been shown to have the potential to impact yield in the to but to have been only in model species. It is now important that this knowledge is fully in Clearly, the reduction of the Rubisco oxygenase reaction a target for future improvement of photosynthesis. However, the strategies that might be to achieve this goal are all of these approaches will be fundamental to identify the of the C3 cycle is not about increasing CO2 fixation but should also to increase and water while high manipulation of the C3 cycle to improve these is also an important The range of and that are now together with the development and application of in to allow analysis of a range of species in natural will the analysis of natural in photosynthetic carbon This approach has and potential for future exploitation to improve yield through manipulation of the C3 cycle.
Institution: University of Essex
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2139294585
FWCI: 1.119
Cites: 53
Cited by: 402
Related to: 10