NAFTA and WTO Dispute Settlement Rules – A Thematic Comparison
Year: 1997
Type: article
Abstract: Systems for trade dispute settlement are rarely conceived in purely abstract terms.Indeed, like most legal regimes, they often arise and evolve through a combination of borrowing from successful efforts of the past, together with innovations to meet the perceived need for the future.This process can be recognized in the dispute settlement process of the 1989 Free Trade Agreement between Canada and the United States1 (FTA) and the 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) .2The similarities between the dispute settlement rules of the FTA and those used under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT)~ were impressive.It was not unreasonable to expect that the United States and Canada, when they set up the FTA, borrowed from practices developed in the GATT forum where they had always been active users of the dispute settlement mechanism.William Davey, in his Pine and Swine critique of the FTA case-law, goes further and claims that: "[The FTA] dispute settlement provisions were, by and large, the same as the WTO/GATT procedures as they emerged from the Uruguay Round.Indeed some of the Uruguay Round innovations in the GATT/WTO procedures were first implemented in the Canada-U.S. FTA."~This article will try to develop Davey's affirmation and assess whether this GATT/FTA interaction process has continued between the dispute settlement rules of the
Source: Journal of World Trade
DOI: 10.54648/trad1997010
Author: Gabrielle Marceau
Language: English
Topic: World Trade Organization Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2153758366
