Work

Eventful and Critical Junctures: What is the Difference and Why is it Important?

Year: 2013
Type: preprint
Abstract: The notion of a critical juncture has been used by many scholars to enhance their understanding of the origins of institutions. At a basic level, critical junctures often refer to the point in time that marks the beginning of a different trajectory. The existence of a critical juncture is a crucial part of many historically contingent causal explanations of significant political phenomena (e.g. Collier and Collier 2002; Ikenberry 2001; Pierson 2004). There may be variations in the characteristics attributed to the different conceptions of critical junctures used by many scholars but one feature they tend to have in common is the focus on the aftermath or effect of the juncture - the new trajectory - while ignoring the dynamics of the juncture itself. The reliance on this kind of theoretical understanding produces a unilinear process where the sequential steps necessary to produce a distinct trajectory are the direct result of a strongly determined process from which there is no alternative. The change in trajectory had to happen. The focus on the aftermath of junctures assumes away the ability to identify which moments are contingent and eliminates the ability to counterfactually examine what was possible at the time. Critical junctures become a “Black Box” from which scholars can see the inputs from preexisting structures and the outputs of the new institutional arrangement but they cannot explain what takes place within the box. Rather than rely on an effect-based understanding of critical junctures I propose that scholars use the notion of an eventful juncture where constraints on actors are relaxed, opening possibilities for action. Actors face choices which were not previously available. Actors’ decisions during eventful junctures create the path while the alternatives can be evaluated counterfactually. Critical and uncritical junctures can then be examined to understand the dynamics of eventful junctures. The identification of which junctures are critical and which are uncritical can contribute to understanding why some junctures lead to different trajectories while others do not. I use examples from the end of the Cold War and the U.S. decision to request international authorization for the projection of military force to illustrate the theoretical and methodological implications of eventful junctures.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2215212595
Cites: 49
Cited by:
Related to: 10