Work

Actional and relational verbs in newspaper editorials

Year: 1996
Type: article
Abstract: 1. Introduction In this paper, we will analyse 60 editorials from British newspapers The Sun and The Times, using lateral verb model outlined in Kress and Hodge's (1979) Language as Ideology, a seminal work that advocates closer ties between linguistics, sociology and psychology. A study of newspaper discourse should require no justification because it is probably both most read of all text types and that of which greatest volume is printed. Moreover, two papers in question, both owned by Rupert Murdoch, represent two ends of press spectrum: The Sun is Britain's top-selling tabloid daily, known for its sensationalist scandalmongering; while The Times has long been considered a venerable organ of establishment. Our starting hypothesis is that differing styles of these two papers owe something of their distinctiveness to writers' choices of verb types as carriers of new information. Thus, we will determine relative proportions of various Relational and Actional verbs, in above model, used in each paper. Where statistics for The Sun and The Times differ, we will attempt to discern rhetorical motivation for this. 2. Theoretical background Kress and Hodge (1979) explain that perception is not purely psychological, but dependent on language, which reconstitutes world and provides systematic organising assumptions through which we see reality. As practical consciousness of society, language is: inevitably a partial and false consciousness. We can call it ideology, defining ideology as a systematic body of ideas, organized from a particular point of view (Kress -- Hodge 1979:6). More practically, for our purposes, language is: an instrument of control as well as of communication. Linguistic forms allow significance to be conveyed and to be distorted. In this way hearers can be both manipulated and informed, preferably manipulated while they suppose they are being informed (Kress - Hodge 1979:6). Whereas Theme generally gives prominence to certain actors and sets agenda for a message, some schemata - which according to Kress and Hodge, classify events in world - are principally carried by Rheme. Among these is one they call Lateral model. Focused on verb, it portrays reality in terms of two sub-models, Actional and Relational, and these provide theoretical framework for present study. The Actional submodel, firstly, relates one entity - Actor - to another - Affected - by a process (Transactive) or, alternatively, a single entity and a process (Non-Transactive). The Relational submodel, secondly, involves writer comments on entities or actions. Again, there are two types of Relationals: Attributives describe and are either Possessive (eg. Bill has courage) or Qualitative (eg. Paula is brilliant); Equatives equate two concepts, usually entities, (eg. John is President). Kress and Hodge claim for their model, which they call essentially semantic, a higher degree of rigour and delicacy than was possible with traditional distinction between transitive and intransitive. Unlike latter, for instance, their lateral model would not confuse actions and non-actions (eg. the parcel weighs ten pounds). Unfortunately, a semantic analysis is at least partially dependent on reader interpretation. This means that even their model fails to clarify, definitively, philosophical question of what constitutes an action in a world subject to perpetual change (Halliday 1993:23). So as not to become embroiled in Kantian dilemma of subjective versus objective reality, therefore, we opted to employ following simplified model: A. Kress and Hodge's lateral model, reduced to: B. Analysis was by form only, though we noted instances in which form and function diverged. C. Ignoring Kress and Hodge's mental versus physical process dichotomy, we nevertheless aimed at a measure of delicacy by including following subcategories: a) Within Active Transactives - abstract object indirect object abstract subject AND object abstract subject reflexive subject/object b) Within Passive Transactives - implied subject explicit subject no subject D. …
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W223970195
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10