Whose on Third? Black Electoral Complexity and 'Third Wave' Mayoral Leadership Claims
Year: 2012
Type: preprint
Abstract: The purpose of this paper is to examine how African American voters sort out the claims of Black mayoral candidates who claim the mantle of transformative leadership in this so-called post Obama era. We focus upon the re-election campaign of controversial Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick as he was challenged by a political insider, Freeman Hendrix. We test Thompson’s (2006) provocative thesis -- “the Dirty Little Secret of Black Politics” -- which presumes, overtime, African American mayors do not actively court the black poor as members of their electoral coalitions because of the fiscal and political costs of meeting these constituents’ needs over the needs of the middle and upper classes who ask for growth and economic development. Thompson asserts that whereas a “Third Wave” of black politicians -- such as Mayor Harold Washington of Chicago or David Dinkins of New York -- have averted this dilemma and explicitly built grassroots alliances, previous cohorts of “civil rights” mayors and “technocratic” mayors did or have not. Merging and analyzing data from Detroit’s 2005 mayoral primary and general elections with 2000 census data, we find that Kilpatrick’s re-election coalition (which had elements of the old-style, civil rights generation leadership) beat back the challenge of Hendrix (a second wave, technocratic leadership style) as both made implicit claims about being (Third Wave) transformative leaders. But neither of their campaigns neatly fit into Thompson’s interesting typology, partly due to how age, class, and gender mattered in unanticipated ways. In this regard, we believe this work is not only an interesting addition to the work in black political participation but further suggests that the mobilization of black grassroots constituencies in this new era is not as easy as a candidate calling for symbolic racial representation.
Source: SSRN Electronic Journal
Authors: Todd C. Shaw, Athena M. King
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2265626534
