Work

What next for rural education research?

Year: 2015
Type: editorial
Abstract: Where are we going in rural education research?Looking at the field over the last decade indicates an overwhelming focus on preparing teachers for rural schools, a concern on rural student achievement, on access to higher education (e,g.Bradley, 2008) and on high-stakes testing (e.g.Gonski, 2011) .While these streams of research are important, they are bound by a view of rural schooling as lacking and disadvantaged vis a vis their metropolitan counterparts.In the process the rural is often 'othered' in comparison to a metropolitan norm.Nearly a decade ago Arnold and colleagues (2005) reviewed the 'condition' of rural education research with the aim of proposing a new agenda.In this review they argued that there were few experimental or comparative studies and proposed an agenda that addressed this perceived limitation.While they did acknowledge the difference of the rural and the need of researchers to understand school-community links, they largely suggested what may now be seen as a positivist and neoliberal influenced agenda.Commenting critically, this agenda seems aimed at understanding the causes of the average lower outcomes for rural students and examining approaches to ensure achievement tends more towards the average.This proposed agenda provoked a much-cited response by Howley, Theobold and Howley (2005) who questioned: 'What rural education research is of most worth?'In so doing, they challenged the positivist and overcoming deficit orientation to all things rural to instead suggest rural education research must engage with rural meanings and rural places as valuable and important.This, they argued, necessitated an orientation to understanding what works for rural communities -rather than for government bureaucracies or national business-and may involve more qualitative approaches than Arnold and colleagues proposed.Howley, Howley and Yahn (2014) recently returned to this critique about the nature of rural research, by suggesting that much rural research focuses upon overcoming the implied deficiencies of rural people and places, with the rural being somewhat of an afterthought -that is, the rural is not valued in its own right or seen as generative to the research.In this sense, they reaffirm the idea that the rural 'lifeworld' that shapes what happens in schools is a key component of any rigorous rural education research.While the debate cited above emanates from a North American context, its gesturing was towards the field in general.These concerns were by no means North American only.Going back a decade further, Sher and Sher's (1994) seminal article asked researchers to genuinely value (Australia's) rural people and communities.They pleaded with us to undertake our work 'as if rural people and communities really mattered' (Sher & Sher, 1994).We note however that this article was also in relation to 'rural development' so was subtly informed by the lingering rural Roberts, P. & Cuervo, H. (2015).What next for rural education research?Australian and International Journal of Rural Education, Vol. 25 (3), pp.1-8.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W2272093704
Cites: 32
Cited by: 55
Related to: 10