Estudio De Durabilidad De Cañas De Oboe a Partir De Parámetros De Calidad Sonora
Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: [EN] This Doctoral Thesis is a study of the durability of the oboe's double bladed mouthpiece (commonly known as "reed") and has tried to address the topic from various perspectives. An objective point of view was taken in an acoustic analysis of the reeds through thousands of measurements while a more subjective angle was taken through an evaluation of the opinions of professional musicians, people with musical knowledge and the general public.\nThis Doctoral Thesis has been elaborated in several phases. In the first phase, nine reeds of three different models (Alfa, Alliaud and unnamed cane harvested by myself) were made. In this phase, reed behavior was measured as a function of the hours each had been played whilst parameters which might influence the quality of the reed were investigated: acoustics in which it was played, notated opinions by professional colleagues, chemical parameters such as pH. \nIn a second phase, fifteen reeds were made using cane from five different sources (three reeds from each source), including four specialized companies: Alfa, Alliaud, Le Roseau Chantant and Kge Reed's own collection, Villajoyosa (Alicante). At this stage, more concrete results were sought.\nThree intermittent recording sessions were performed over time: the first on December 23, 2013 after the reeds were freshly made and barely used, the second on April 16, 2014 when the reeds were half-worn out, and the third on July 9, 2014, when it was time to discard the reeds due to the end of their functioning lifespan. The recordings were made in the anechoic chamber of the Polytechnic University of Gandia, in the Aula Magna of the University and also in a reverberant hall using various systems of recording equipment: the Symphonie, a 2250 Sound Level Meter and HATS. We asked for the collaboration of another oboist to investigate results of changing the musician without changing the instrument or reed.\nThese files have been analyzed objectively by looking for harmonic patterns of behaviour. It has been found that those reeds that are considered ideal produce harmonic patterns which are quite similar (up to the 4th or 5th harmonic) while reeds in a state of disrepair display marked differences in these harmonics. It has been determined that the deterioration of the upper order of these harmonics is a function of the number of hours of the reed's use. It was also found that upon leaving the anechoic chamber, harmonic patterns were distorted by the acoustic effects of the hall or room. Another important fact is that the harmonic patterns of the good reeds made in the first phase (2005) largely coincide with those of the reeds made in the second phase (2013). This lends stability and consistency to the harmonic analysis.\nWith regard to the subjective part, through a specialized internet surveys page, a hearing-survey was designed consisting of fourteen different sound fragments to be listened to and evaluated. We achieved wide participation with 447 people completing the survey correctly, of which over 200 have a degree in music. The results of the surveys have been analyzed in detail. After a filtering based on various sectors of the population, different conclusions were obtained. The most noteworthy are that the opinions of the performer and the listener do not always coincide; the interpretative sensation sometimes differs from that of the listener, with respect to the functionality and sonorous quality of the reed. The influence of the room enhances the perception of the listener, and can even partly mask the flaws of a mediocre reed. An interpreter who makes his own reeds can play on one that is sub-par but still attain a feeling that the reed is good. However, different interpreters cannot exchange reeds and still play comfortably as was determined in the subjective part.
Author: JUAN PEDRO ROMERO NIETO
Language: Spanish
Subfield: Music
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: oboe reeds, harmonic analysis, oboe performance
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2304428131
