Work

Test Re-Test Reliability and Validity of Different Visual Acuity and Stereoacuity Charts Used in Preschool Children

Year: 2015
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: IntrOductIOnPreschool vision screenings are inevitable to detect visual impairment among the children attending preschools [1,2].Amblyopia, squint and refractive error are the common vision disorders seen in childhood [2,3].The primary aim of screening children at a young age is to reduce the prevalence of amblyopia by referring them when they are still amenable to treatment.Uncorrected amblyopia can hamper the ability to learn thereby affecting the school performance.It gradually wobbles the adult's self-image in later years.Recognition acuity is more sensitive than grating or detection acuity for identifying amblyopia [4].The most important aspect in testing the visual acuity of preschool children is the selection of tests that require cognitive skills appropriate for the children's age.The indispensable components for effective use of any visual acuity charts in young children are the ability of the child to perform the task (test ability), the ability of the test to accurately differentiate the children who have an ocular disorder from those children who do not have (sensitivity and specificity) and the reliability of the tests [5].In screening for visual impairment, US Preventive Service Task Force recommended Lea Symbols, HOTV and Tumbling E charts.They also found that early detection of amblyopia improves visual acuity [6].Little age specific information is available concerning the diagnostic validity of these tests for preschoolers in the developing world.However, reports are available on wide usage of C and E-charts in Asian countries, where English is not the native language [7].Many studies have compared the visual acuity results obtained by the use of Landolt C and E-charts in this age group.There is paucity of published data on the diagnostic validity of these charts in India.Stereopsis is the uppermost form of the binocular coordination function and its assessment is an integral part of the routine binocular vision examinations.Stereo acuity measures are sensitive to developmental disorders of vision such as amblyopia, strabismus, uncorrected refractive errors and ocular pathologies that reduce the visual acuity [8].The purpose of current study was to compare the reliability, sensitivity and specificity of visual acuity charts (Lea symbol, HOTV and E-charts) and stereo acuity charts (Titmus and Frisby) in preschool children. MAtErIALs And MEtHOdsA cross-sectional study was conducted in a preschool of a semi urban locality in Udupi District of Karnataka, India from August 2013 to March 2014.Anticipating 75% repeatability, an allowable difference of 10% and non cooperation rate of 20%, a minimum sample size of 87 was arrived at.The school had 150 children on roll.All the children were screened for the visual deficit.A total of 90 subjects (180 eyes) were recruited for the study based on the cooperation level.Age range of the study subjects were between 36 to 71 months.Children with strabismus, systemic diseases, developmental delay, attention deficits, or any ocular diseases, were excluded from the study based on examination and the records available.Computerised random number table was used to generate the order of presentation of the charts to the study subjects.Monocular assessment of visual acuity was performed in both eyes with the Lea Symbols, HOTV and E-chart followed by stereo acuity measurement using Titmus and Frisby stereo cards.A thorough binocular vision examination was done followed by anterior segment evaluation with hand held slit lamp.Posterior segment evaluation was performed using direct ophthalmoscope through
Language: English
Subfield: Ophthalmology
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $275
OpenAlex ID: W2336629863
FWCI: 2.691
Cites: 32
Cited by: 53
Related to: 10