Year: 1989
Type: article
Abstract: AmTRAcT.-In this review the evidence for the existence of interspecific competition between members of the genus Purus is organized according to the time scale involved.Competition on an ecological time scale is amenable to experimental manipulation, whereas the effects of competition on an evolutionary time scale are not, Therefore the existence of competition has to be inferred mainly from comparisons between populations.Numerical effects of interspecific competition in coexisting populations on population parameters have been shown in several studies of Great and Blue tits (Parus major and P. caerulm) during the breeding season and during winter, and they have been suggested for the Black-capped Chickadee (P.atricapillus) and the Tufted Titmouse (P.bicolor).It is argued that the doubly asymmetric two-way interspecific competition between Great and Blue tits would have a stabilizing effect promoting their coexistence.Functional effects on niche use have been experimentally shown by removal or cage experiments between Willow (P.montanus) and Marsh (P.pahstris) tits, between Willow and Crested tits (P.cristatus) and Coal Tits (P.ater) and Goldcrests (Regulus reguh), and between Coal and Willow tits.Non-manipulative studies suggest the existence of interspecific competition leading to rapid niche shifts between Crested and Willow tits and between Great and Willow tits.Evolutionary responses that can be explained as adaptations to variations in the importance of interspecific competition are numerous.An experiment failed to show that Blue Tit populations, subjected to different levels of interspecific competition by Great Tits, underwent divergent micro-evolutionary changes for body size.It thus remains unclear what time scale is involved in the presumed adaptations to interspecific competition.The problem with interspecific competition is that some people believe it is such an important force which is a transient phenomenon that can be observed only rarely in nature, whereas others think it is so important that it permanently influences coexisting species-populations.This difference in opinion, also concerning titmice, existed 35 years ago.Kluyver (195 1, 1966) wrote that interspecific competition between Great Tits (Par-US major) and Blue Tits (P.cueruleus) existed, but that since intraspecific competition among Great Tits was more important than interspecific competition between the two species, he would only consider the first.From the context of these statements it seems he meant that Blue Tit numbers influenced some aspect of Great Tit population dynamics.Unfortunately, he did not present evidence to support his claim.Lack (1945) argued that closely related species coexisting in the same habitat differ in ecological niche, especially in foraging niche, in order to avoid competition.These niche differences are the result of their evolu-' Dept.
Author: Dhondt, André A
Language: English
Topic: Avian ecology and behavior
Subfield: Ecology
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Keywords: interspecific competition, Paridae, Parus, Parus major, blue tit, coexistence, niche shift, body size evolution, microevolution, adaptive evolution, intraspecific competition, population dynamics, experimental manipulation, cage experiments, Purus, Parus montanus, Parus cristatus, black-capped chickadee, Regulus
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2339827602
