Work

China and Eu Antitrust Review of Refusal to License Ipr

Year: 2015
Type: book
Abstract: POTENTIAL) TUTOR?Maklu refusal to license behaviour would be treated as abuse of dominant position, chapter 5 examines in details the envisaged substantial criteria on refusal to license within the draft AML IP Guideline and the draft IP Enforcement Regulation.It could be observed that the Chinese lawmakers have in the latest draft of IP Enforcement Regulation adopted a lower standard to establish an abusive refusal to license.On the one hand, the substantial criteria proposed in the draft AML IP Guideline appears closer to the EU approach compared to the much broader essential facility provision provided in the draft IP Enforcement Regulation.On the other hand, both of the draft AML IP Guideline and the draft IP Enforcement Regulation are divergent, to varying degrees, with EU's 'exceptional circumstances test' in many respects.The author thus proposes firstly that the IP Enforcement Regulation should set the tone for the AML IP Guideline owning to their different roles in the competition law system.As to the substantial criteria within the IP Enforcement Regulation on refusal to license, the author recommends revising Article 7 to contain two parts: a general principle and the exceptional circumstances to establish abusive refusals.It is vital to revise current essential facility provision in the draft IP Enforcement Regulation into the EU-like exceptional circumstances.It should be noted that there have been two standards in the EU case law.Considering that it is unlikely that the IP Enforcement Regulation would completely copy the strict criteria set out in IMS Health, it may be realistic to re-set the Chinese version of competition criteria on refusal to license in between the EU Magill/IMS Health standard and the Microsoft I standard.As to the potential AML IP Guideline, based on the criteria set out in the IP Enforcement Regulation, more detailed guidance on assessing refusal to license conduct could be provided after obtaining experience from enforcement authority's future activities.Chapter 5 also reviews the excessive pricing and FRANDrelated provisions within the legal instruments and practice in China, demonstrating that in this respect China generally takes an EU-like position.A final remark in this book relates to the institutional reform in China, with the aim of overcoming the problems within the current enforcement regime (including inter-authority and intra-authority problems).After finding that merging the three competition law enforcement authorities into one single, independent EU Commission-like enforcement authority is not feasible in the foreseeable future, the author proposes to pursue the second best -merging the two competition law divisions under the NDRC and the SAIC into one agency in charge of non-merger cases.m a k l u 1 For the EU see, inter alia, EU Commission, Guidelines on the application of Article 101 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union to technology transfer agreements, 28 March 2014, OJ C 89/03, Para 7, 'Intellectual property rights promote dynamic competition by encouraging undertakings to invest in developing new or improved products and processes.So does competition by putting pressure on undertakings to innovate.Therefore, both intellectual property rights and competition are necessary to promote innovation and ensure a competitive exploitation thereof'.For the US see, Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission, Antitrust Guidelines for the Licensing of Intellectual Property, 6 April 1995, §1.0, 'The intellectual property laws and the antitrust law share the common purpose of promoting innovation and enhancing consumer welfare'; US Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission in the introduction of the Antitrust Enforcement & IPRs: Promoting Innovation and Competition (2007) reiterate that 'antitrust enforcers and the courts have to recognize that intellectual property laws and antitrust laws share the same fundamental goals of enhancing consumer welfare and promoting innovation.' 2 Economic analysis in the field of intellectual property rights see, for instance, Edmund W.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2346957833
FWCI: 0.513
Cites: 130
Cited by: 3
Related to: 9