Work

Behind the scenes ofJAC: the Editor-in-Chief

Year: 2016
Type: article
Abstract: I have now been Editor-in-Chief for just over a year and believe I now have a fuller picture of what the job entails. It is not what I originally thought but involves a variety of tasks of which I was wholly ignorant before I was appointed to follow in the footsteps of Professor Alan Johnson. As I reflect on the last year, my admiration for all my predecessors only increases. The job is officially part-time but it is quite easy to spend many more hours besides assigning submissions for review, dealing with enquiries, complaints, metrics, strategy and so on. Currently the journal receives around 30–50 new submissions each week. The monthly rate of submissions has not changed significantly in the last 2 years and the trend looks set to continue this year and, although there are slight peaks and troughs, the rate remains essentially steady (Figure 1). Most articles are submitted between Tuesday and Thursday (Figure 2). Consequently, I split the workload and allocate assignments twice weekly, currently on Tuesdays and Fridays. This helps achieve a steady flow and a manageable workload for the Senior Editors (Table 1). JAC Editorial Board 2016 JAC Editorial Board 2016 JAC submissions by month, 2014 and 2015. This figure appears in colour in the online version of JAC and in black and white in the print version of JAC. Proportion of articles submitted to JAC according to the day of the week (2015). I first consider whether each article meets the aims and scope of the Journal and the Senior Editors judge the papers they are assigned for quality, merit, and interest to our readers. Those that fail to pass muster are rejected immediately while the remainder are then assigned by the Senior Editors to one of 41 Editors according to their expertise. The Editors (Table 1) then set out to secure two reviewers who are asked to provide their verdict within 2 weeks of agreeing to act as referee. This structure allows us to inform authors as quickly as possible if we decide not to accept an article. A quick verdict, even if unfavourable, is always appreciated. In fact, surprisingly few authors whose papers have been immediately rejected actually lodge an appeal. Those of you whom we have disappointed will be familiar with the opening line in my letter of rejection: I have reviewed it and decided to return it to you without sending it out to review. This is not a reflection on the quality of your work but is based how well the subject fits the aims and scope of the journal and its appeal to our general readership. Or that from the Senior Editors: I regret to inform you that having considered your article we are unable to give it sufficient priority to consider it further and have therefore rejected it. These letters end with a statement about our being sorry to disappoint on this occasion which is sincerely meant and we really do hope these adverse decisions will not dissuade their recipients unduly from considering submission to JAC in the future. One of my tasks is to ensure that the rejection rate remains around four in every five submissions so that we stay within our budgeted page allocation. Without going into details, this is part of the agreement made between the Journal, BSAC and our publisher, Oxford University Press. This allows us to select what we consider the best offerings and keep a high standard for the articles that are eventually published. If that were all I had to do, I could easily fit this in to the 2 days allocated to this task, but, as with much else in life, appearances can be, and usually are, deceptive. The Journal aims to provide a verdict, whether favourable or not, as quickly as possible, typically within 6 weeks of receipt. However, this is not always possible for several reasons. Securing reviewers presents a particular challenge even when authors supply suggestions. Fortunately, ScholarOne is now equipped with a reviewer-identifying tool that provides potential reviewers for the Editor to consider. It is often forgotten that our reviewers volunteer their time to perform the service and most, if not all, undertake this task out of office hours. As they are mostly very busy people, they may not be able to complete the review within the 14 days allotted. When we invite reviewers we do ask them if they require an extension but often any delay in lodging a report is unintentional and results from having too many competing priorities. Every reviewer receives reminders when their report is overdue and most respond quickly and complete the review. Inevitably, this is not always the case so the office keeps a close eye on every delay and makes every attempt to remedy the situation. Moreover, we receive approximately 10 enquiries each week about the status of papers where there is a delay and, of the 108 enquiries received in the last 11 months, delayed reviewer reports accounted for two-thirds. While 59% of these enquiries were perfectly justified as they were made ≥8 weeks after submission, the remainder were made on, or before, the threshold we use for defining a delay (Figure 3). Nevertheless, authors are right to expect a speedy turnaround of their papers, which is one of the journal's hallmarks. These enquiries are only made on about 5% of all new submissions; the Editorial Team always attempts to forestall these delays and keep them to a bare minimum. In every case, the office writes to the authors to explain the reason and also communicates with the Editor and the reviewers asking them to progress to a rapid decision. This might entail relying only on the Editor's appraisal and a single referee report, securing new external reviewers or even calling on another Editor to provide a rapid review. It is always more palatable if the recommendation is to accept or ask for a revision. Understandably, a decision to reject the paper not only disappoints the authors but also, rightly, leaves them unhappy about the delay. It also creates a particularly awkward situation for the Editorial Team as such delays potentially tarnish the Journal's reputation; for this reason I intervene when appropriate and offer our apologies in writing. Number of status enquiries from authors by week post-submission. I was very fortunate to have inherited an editorial structure from my predecessors, particularly Professor Johnson, who established the two-tier system of Senior Editors and Editors. Apart from screening and assigning submissions, Senior Editors act autonomously and deal directly with any appeals or complaints about a given submission. They also form what can best be described as the ‘cabinet’. We meet twice a year, once face-to-face, typically in the spring, and again in the autumn for an online meeting. I rely on each of them to help shape the Journal's strategy and refine the systems we have in place to maintain the Journal's quality as well as to identify problems and suggest improvements. I also expect them to be brutally honest if need be and to share their comments plainly. I am pleased to say they are usually more than happy to oblige! Just before the end of 2015, Professor Leibovici informed me that he had accepted the position of Editor-in-Chief of Clinical Microbiology and Infection. This was a severe and sudden blow to the JAC as he has a vast experience in epidemiology, systematic reviews and all things concerning clinical trials. Of course we were all very pleased at his promotion but it did leave us one Senior Editor down and a substantial gap in expertise. Clearly a replacement was needed. Moreover, there were other apparent gaps in expertise and also the need to avoid overloading the Senior Editors. Hence we sought suitable candidates from among the existing Editors. We identified several and following extensive discussions with them and the ‘cabinet’ we were able to appoint John Perry, Athanassios Tsakris and Engeline van Duijkeren, who started in their new role on 1 April—after midday of course! This meant that we had to recruit new volunteers to act as Editors and were fortunate in being able to appoint Diane Ashiru-Oredope, Russell Lewis, Anouk Muller, David van Duin, Sally Partridge and David Jenkins. The full Editorial Team and their provenance is shown in Table 1 and full details can be found on the JAC web site (http://www.oxfordjournals.org/our_journals/jac/editorial_board.html). Those who are familiar with the Editorial Board will have noticed that more than half of our Editors are based in continental Europe. This reflects the international character of the journal (Figure 4). Editors are no longer appointed for a fixed term of 3 years (with a possible extension for a further 3 years). This change has had no noticeable ill effects on the Journal. However, there will inevitably be changes over the course of time. Readers who feel they have much to offer to the journal as an Editor are welcome to contact me at any time. Geographical distribution of current Editorial Board members. The bulk of articles received are reports of original research but the Journal is always seeking authors to contribute reviews and leading articles that comment and reflect on developments in all facets of antimicrobial chemotherapy. Happily, we receive a steady stream of offers on a variety of topics. I look carefully at each and every one and typically ask for a synopsis of the intended article so I can decide whether or not the article is suitable for the Journal. I also deal with every complaint addressed to me and intervene when authors lodge an appeal about our verdict but are not satisfied with the response received from the Senior Editor responsible. Whilst most authors are content with this, there have been a few occasions where the authors in question could not contain their outrage and allowed it to colour their correspondence. There have been only a few intractable authorship disputes to deal with but, as with complaints and appeals, they do consume a considerable amount of time and energy in crafting suitable responses. Fortunately, I have mastered some of the diplomatic skills I so admired in my father and slavishly follow his advice to be courteous, concise and clear. I attend the BSAC Executive and Council meetings every quarter as a non-voting participant to inform BSAC Council about the Journal as well as keep myself abreast of the BSAC's interests and activities. This also allows me to meet the Journal staff who are based at BSAC Headquarters and share any concerns that we may have. I also attend two Publications Committee meetings, which precede the April and October Council meetings. To prepare for these gatherings, Colin Drummond (Editorial Manager), Phil Bishop (our Senior Publisher at OUP) and I meet ahead of each Council meeting to fully acquaint ourselves with all matters relating to publishing, which include production (copyediting and proof preparation), metrics, threats and opportunities as well as new developments in the publishing arena. I also get involved in marketing, which pushes me a bit beyond my comfort zone to say the least. Fortunately, Laura Orchard, Portfolio Marketing Executive, OUP, is there to help and has proven invaluable in establishing the monthly Editor's choice and in guiding me through the process of selecting suitable articles for various campaigns placed on the JAC web site as well as via social media. I am also actively engaged in securing potential Supplements, together with Carolina Vicente, Special Sales Account Manager, OUP, and Tracey Guise, CEO of the BSAC. Last, but by no means least, I am actually able to use some of my acquired skills in data capture, analysis and presentation, which has allowed us to develop metrics that are better suited to the Journal and its activities. For instance, we now have tools for measuring Editor performance, including timeliness, to help keep turnaround times to a minimum and identify potential bottlenecks as early as possible, so they can be eliminated. Of course I would not be able to function properly without the able assistance of Clare Jeeves and Suzanne Brockhouse, but especially Colin Drummond. He has much longer experience of the Journal than I have and helps me not only to fulfil my role but also by providing the necessary checks and balances that every new kid on the block needs. My position would also be untenable without the support of Tracey Guise, Dilip Nathwani (BSAC President), and Conor Jamieson (BSAC Honorary Treasurer), who are, in effect, the owners of the Journal and my employer. We each have a distinctive role to play in ensuring the success of the Journal, maintaining its standing in the scientific community and securing its future, but as Editor-in-Chief I am fully aware that ultimate responsibility rests with me and am content to be judged by my performance, however that is measured. None to declare.
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2419083961
FWCI: 0.855
Cites:
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10