Identifying and Intervening with Beginning Readers Who Are At-Risk for Dyslexia: Advances in Individualized Classroom Instruction.
Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: Researchers have demonstrated that students with dyslexia share a phonological linguistic deficit (Catts, Fey, Zhang, & Tomblin, 1999; Shaywitz, Fletcher, & Holahan, 1999). This deficit may be “unexpected,” but it manifests very early when children have difficulties in learning about letters, sounds, rhymes, and language relative to their peers with similar home literacy experiences. When these early difficulties persist, they strongly predict which students are likely to develop difficulties with reading accuracy, fluency, and comprehension. Researchers have shown us that we could greatly reduce reading disabilities if we identified (accurately and early) children who are at-risk for reading difficulties, and if we provided those children with evidence-based instruction immediately. Converging findings from over four decades of psychological and educational research show which instructional methods help most children learn to read (National Reading Panel, 2000).
It is encouraging, therefore, that general and special education policy (namely the Reading First Initiative of the No Child Left Behind Act and the reauthorization of the Individuals with Disabilities Act) allow school districts to “use a process that determines if the child responds to scientific, research-based intervention as a part of the evaluation procedures” for learning disabilities. The goal of using such a process, known as Response to Instruction or Intervention (RTI) is to eliminate ineffective reading instruction as a cause of reading difficulties. Further, this RTI process could alleviate the need for children at-risk for reading difficulties to wait to receive reading intervention services until they have demonstrated a relatively severe and unexpected discrepancy relative to their intelligence (IQ-achievement discrepancy). Thus, with RTI, early intervening services are provided for struggling beginning readers before they fall farther and farther behind their peers and show severe discrepancies between their reading and cognitive abilities.
Prevention is far more powerful than remediation, so we are optimistic about RTI; at the same time we share concerns expressed by parents, practitioners, and fellow researchers that there are not yet a set of RTI “standard operating procedures.” Our purpose in addressing Perspectives on Language and Literacy readers is not to provide a comprehensive guide to RTI, but to share our considerable research experience helping schools who are beginning to implement RTI, particularly emphasizing the early grades where the research is most strong.
The research on early intervention is particularly compelling, so we are sharing the vision of what can happen at the early grades when all students receive the benefit of early intervention.
It is also important to provide intervention to older students, who desperately need, but too often do not receive, the intensive remedial multicomponent instruction necessary to help them read grade-level texts.In this article, we do not directly address RTI for older students with more severe reading or writing disabilities, but other authors in this issue do.
First, we describe an overview of the RTI implementation process. Next, we illustrate from our own research ways to maximize resources within beginning reading instruction. Then, we discuss implementation issues related to identifying children who need additional intervention. We conclude with some additional considerations and solutions.
Source: PubMed
Authors: Stephanie Al Otaiba, Carol McDonald Connor, Barbara Foorman, Christopher Schatschneider, Luana Greulich, Jessica Folsom Sidler
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2431334191
