Work

Changing Definitions of Money, Nature, and Equality c. 1140-1270, reflected in Thomas Aquinas' Question on Usury

Year: 2005
Type: article
Abstract: . In Gratian’s Decretum (c. 1140), usury was argued to be contra naturam because it created an « unnatural » inequality between borrower and lender. The argument rested on three definitional pillars : that of money, of equality, and of nature itself. In the period that separated the Decretum from St. Thomas’ questions on usury in the Summa theologica (c. 1270), each of these definitions changed profoundly. After outlining these changes, I investigate the difficulties St. Thomas was forced to overcome in order to continue to define usury as a violation of natural equality. I conclude that he was forced to disregard Aristotle’s insights into the nature of both money and equality, even as he centered his argument in an Aristotelian vision of nature. And while the root of his objection to usury may have been moral and ethical, changes in the definition of equality over the thirteenth century, particularly in regard to economic exchange, forced him to abandon the moral and ethical arguments that had formed the basis of the traditional Christian case against usury.
Source: Persée
Author: Joel Kaye
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2467217397
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 10
Related to: 9