Work

Factors affecting the spatiotemporal distribution of moose, with a special emphasis on supplementary feeding

Year: 2010
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Large herbivores constitute an important natural resource and are actively managed to\nmeet economic, conservation and environmental objectives. To alleviate the potential of\nresource limitation and damage to commercially important habitats in areas with high\npopulation densities, the provisioning of artificial or supplementary forage has become a\npopular wildlife management intervention throughout Europe and North America.\nHowever, the usefulness of supplementary feeding is equivocal and little is known about\nhow it affects spatiotemporal distribution patterns of large herbivores.\nThe main aim of this thesis is to quantify the effect of supplementary feeding on\nthe spatiotemporal distribution of moose (Alces alces L. 1758) living in southern Norway.\nI used locations of free-ranging GPS (global positioning system) collared moose (N = 26\nin summer and N = 32 in winter) with access to supplementary feeding stations to\nestimate habitat selection and home range size as a function of feeding status (i.e. feeding\nstation users vs. non-users), variation in browse quantity and quality, and also in terms of\nlocal climate and individual characteristics. To evaluate fine-scale distribution patterns\nand foraging decisions around supplementary feeding stations I employed 2 independent\ndatasets (GPS data and browsing estimates) from two study areas (in Telemark and\nHedmark counties) that differ in the length of their feeding history. I apply central-place\nforaging theory to explain the observed patterns.\nMy results indicate that supplementary feeding affects the spatiotemporal\ndistribution of moose only at intermediate to fine spatial scales during winter, with\nfeeding station users behaving as central-place foragers. However, feeding station users\ndid not differ in their large-scale habitat selection patterns or home range size compared\nto non-users. Instead, moose habitat selection was driven by a scale-dependent trade-off\nbetween browse quantity (landscape-scale) and browse quality (within-home rangescale).\nMoreover, depletion of high quality browse during winter lead moose to increase\nselection for lower quality browse within their home range. Variation in home range size\nwas affected by several extrinsic (i.e. climate and natural browse) and intrinsic variables\n(i.e. individual characteristics) and their effects varied between and within spatiotemporal\nscales. After 6 years of feeding, moose that used feeding stations selected for\ncommercially valuable browse (i.e. Scots pine) within their home range to the same\nextent as non-users, which questions the effectiveness of winter feeding in reducing\nbrowsing pressure over large spatial scales. In addition, as the time scale of feeding\nincreased from 5-10 to 15-20 years, browsing pressure on commercially valuable browse\n(i.e. Scots pine and Norway spruce) was amplified at a fine spatial scale. At the same time, resource depletion in the vicinity of feeding stations lead moose to forage at\nincreasing distances from feeding stations and browsing damage occurred at least up to 1\nkm from feeding stations. These findings suggest that when supplementary feeding is\npractised over longer time scales (more than 20 years) there is the potential for a trade off\nto occur between the energetic cost of returning to the central-place (i.e. feeding station)\nand the energetic benefits it provides.\nEvaluating management actions is important to determine whether the objectives\nand desired effects are realized. I have shown how supplementary feeding can affect the\nspatiotemporal distribution of moose and how subsequent browsing pressure around\nfeeding stations can change over time. However, there are a variety of direct and indirect\neffects that follow the provisioning of supplementary forage that have not yet been\nadequately assessed. A holistic evaluation of the effectiveness of supplementary feeding\nas a wildlife management tool is required and needs to consider all the associated benefits\nand costs, especially considering long-term developments and potential ecosystem-level\neffects.
Language: English
Subfield: Ecology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2467221084
Cites: 260
Cited by: 3
Related to: 9