Work

Organizational Conflict and Guidance Systems

Year: 1975
Type: article
Abstract: There is a considerable and growing number of books and articles concerned with guidance and counselling in schools.There are, however, a number of brief points which can be made about this literature.In the first place, much of it is American, and the American experience is not always directly applicable to what happens in this country.In the second place, much of the remainder refers to English schools and this is almost as inapplicable to Scottish schools as the American experience.This is intended not merely as an anti-English jibe but also to make the point that Scottish experience in guidance and counselling differs in a number of respects from that south of the Border.It is significant that, as Rosemary McDonald points out, a publication which ostensibly refers to guidance and counselling in British schools should ignore recent developments in Scotland. 1 Thirdly, much of the literature is concerned with the 'how-to-do-it' and 'how-not-to-do-it' aspects of guidance and counselling work.It has been written mainly by practitioners for those who are interested in the subject.It is often anecdotal and uncritical in approach.To say this is not necessarily to scorn what has been written for such a body of literature is useful for those working in the field or contemplating such work.There are, however, other aspects of the subject which have received less than adequate attention so far.What is required is a rather more systematic and critical collection and evaluation of data.It is worth noting in this context that the American experience with counselling and guidance systems in schools appears to have been almost as under-researched as the British experience. 2 The aim of this article is to comment on the operation of guidance systems in a number of Scottish comprehensive schools.The authors' prime interest is in the organizational aspects of these systems.Very little attention appears to have been paid to this area.3 Certainly there is a lack of research information on the organizational aspects of guidance systems.Furthermore, there is evidence of an organizational naivete in the way these systems were introduced into schools.An American writer, who has studied schools and hospitals, as well as commercial organizations, notes that "for any one organization, the problem is to insure that technology, structure, and goals are in harmony.This is what good management or good leadership is all about." 4 Without exploring the full implications of this remark, it does suggest the key factors that have to be taken into account in the analysis of organizations.In other words, it is not enough simply to set up a system to perform a set of tasks.There are also questions of goals, structure and technology which may be quite complex, but which determine to a large extent the outcome of such systems.Taking this perspective, we look first at the goals of some guidance systems, then at the consequences of the structural changes which have been made as a result of the introduction of these systems.Thirdly, we look at some of the varieties of managerial support for these systems.We obtained the data for the article from five schools in the West of Scotland.In all five schools the guidance systems were set up prior to the publication of the Scottish Education Department Green Paper in 1971, 5 and in each case the guidance system comprised a number of vertical houses -in other words, where the Downloaded from Brill.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W248480965
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10