Results from the 2013 practice owners' economic survey.
Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: Veterinarians who hoped for things to turn around on their own last year must have been very disappointed with 2013. Not only did things not turn around, they got worse. The average companion animal veterinarian in Canada was worse off in 2013 than 2012. Revenues and net incomes were down; the number of clients was down as consumers struggled to come to grips with a lackluster economy.
Revenue and net income are presented in a per full-time equivalent (FTE) standard. Each FTE represents a veterinarian working 1750 hours/year. This is consistent with the average annual hours worked by owners and associate veterinarians. The figures combine owner and associate figures and are presented per veterinarian. This method is used to allow for comparison across veterinary practices with different combinations of owners and associates. For example, by breaking down statistics to a per FTE standard, one could compare statistics for a one doctor hospital with a hospital that has 5 owners and 1 associate or a hospital with 1 owner and 3 associates.
Since 2008, companion animal FTE revenues have only increased by 4.6% nationally. After a surge in 2009, they plummeted in 2010 and have been flat for the past 4 years. In 2013, revenues actually decreased by $2000/FTE veterinarian. After these figures are adjusted for inflation they look even worse. Over the same period, inflation has increased by 10% nationally, while revenues have increased by about half that amount (4.6%). If companion animal revenue had followed the same path as inflation, revenues would be $20 888 higher and net incomes would be a lot higher. The cost-of-living adjusted revenue outperformed actual revenue in every year but 2009.
While veterinarians have been struggling to keep revenues moving forward, the cost of running a veterinary practice has been increasing to higher than the rate of inflation. This explains why net incomes have suffered so much since 2008. After the initial downturn of incomes in 2009, veterinarians tightened their belts and held the line on net incomes until 2013 when net incomes hit an all-time post-recession low coming in at an average of $131 921, 5% lower than the 2008 levels and 15% lower than where they would be if they had followed inflation since 2008 (Figures 1, ,22).
Figure 1
Revenue and net income of veterinarians over the period 2008 to 2013.
Figure 2
Revenue versus cost-of-living adjusted revenue for the period 2008 to 2013.
The driving force behind falling revenues and net incomes is a persistent decline in current clients. By definition, a “current client” is one who has been to the practice in the past 12 months. A 12-month standard is used because it matches the financial reporting period (12 months) and when combined with financial data it can provide production statistics such as client revenue per year.
During prerecession veterinary medicine, the average companion animal veterinarian had 1266 current clients; in 2013, that figure dropped to 888. After a precipitous drop in 2009, client numbers leveled off and many veterinarians thought things would turn around, but the number of current clients dropped again in 2011 and has been falling ever since. Cumulatively, the number of current clients has fallen a whopping 30% since 2008 (Figure 3).
Figure 3
Current and new clients over the period 2008 to 2013.
The decline in numbers of new clients is similar, but weaker, and 2013 presented a glimmer of hope with the number of new clients rebounding for the first time in 3 years.
There are many possible explanations for falling revenues and declining client numbers. One is purely economic. The economy has underperformed since the recession and the persistent struggle to make ends meet has consumers reaching all time highs for personal debt. Simply speaking, the average pet owner has less money available than they did in 2008. All these factors have taken a toll on the consumers psyche and their attitudes toward the current and future economy have hit a 4-year low. According to Pollara Research, a polling company that has been studying consumer’s attitudes for more than a decade, the recession might be over but consumers are still experiencing what they describe as a “psychological recession,” with 54% of Canadian consumers indicating that they feel we are experiencing a recession in 2013 (Figure 4).
Figure 4
Canadians who think the economy is in a recession over the period 2008 to 2013.
Another explanation for the declining number of clients is advanced communication technology. Paradoxically, with all the advances in communication, it is harder to reach a client today than it was 5 years ago. Even with texting, voice-to-text, voice mail, e-mail, phoning home, and phoning the cell phone, the chance of reaching a client on first try is doubtful. The message from the veterinarian for an annual visit is lost in the quagmire of the information age. Many veterinarians are still using 2 postcards and a phone call to contact clients, but that is not working anymore.
Some veterinarians are finding success by trying to ease the financial burden of each client. Wellness plans or bundled services are one way to do this; for example, payments may be split over 12 months instead of clients making a full payment all at once. Clients may not have access to $600 today, but would be happy to pay $50/month for the next 12 months. Fortunately, the banking industry has advanced to handle this new method of payment and the cost of processing 12 smaller payments is comparable to that of processing one big one.
New communication strategies are paying off in some hospitals. Simply increasing the number of times you call the client will have an immediate positive impact on the compliance for annual visits. Your clients are busier now than they used to be in the past, and you have to remind them more often. Pre-booking a year ahead has been a boon in some practices. It takes pressure off the receptionist because with pre-booking they merely remind the client of their appointment. Clients embrace this because it is one less thing for them to worry about.
Examining national trends since 2008 can be very telling. If anything, the persistent negative trends are a cry for a change in management style. Veterinarians waiting for someone to fix the problem for them are going to continue to suffer and will be eclipsed by the veterinarians who are taking charge and redirecting the trend in their hospitals with brute force changes in management style. Owners of successful practices understand they have to change their game and are taking charge. Waiting for someone to fix your problem is not an effective strategy.
Source: PubMed Central
Author: Darren Osborne
Language: English
Subfield: Speech and Hearing
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W27987191
