Year: 2019
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: In a Parsons puzzle, the student must re-assemble the lines of a program that are provided in scrambled order, and eliminate any distracters included within the scrambled lines of code. We investigated two issues in terms of whether they helped students solve the puzzles better: 1) Would it be better to present distracters and the lines of code of which they are a variant paired together or randomly separated apart? 2) Would telling students that they would not be penalized for any mistakes they make before submitting a complete solution for the first time enable them to get closer to the correct solution when they first submit it? We conducted a controlled study over five semesters and used ANOVA to analyze the data collected from introductory programming students who solved Parsons puzzles on if-else statements. We found that when students were told that their puzzle-solving actions before the first submission would not be penalized, they took significantly more exploratory actions. But, their solution was not significantly closer to being correct. So, trial-and-error exploration was no better for solving Parsons puzzles than deliberate approach. Presenting distracters paired together with the original line of code was found to be beneficial only on the longer puzzle.
Author: Amruth N. Kumar
Institution: Ramapo College
Language: English
Subfield: Computer Science Applications
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: bronze
Funder: National Science Foundation
OpenAlex ID: W2963698528
