Work

Contemplative practitioners, becoming teachers: a study of the implications of contemplative practices for teacher professional becoming

Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis explores the implications of contemplative practices for beginning teachers, focusing on issues of identity, being and becoming. In the current neoliberal context, teaching is primarily conceived in terms of decontextualised standards of practice. As a result of this, the question of the ‘who’ of the teacher remains neglected. Contemplative practices, as practices of awareness and self-inquiry, are taken as an avenue to re-open questions of the teacher-self. The purpose of this inquiry is to bring further theoretical clarity and empirical grounding to scholarship regarding contemplative practices and the teacher. It extends existing work by presenting a rich theorisation of the teacher-self, and by exploring contemplative practices defined inclusively, beyond the current preoccupation with mindfulness. The study was guided by the question: What are the implications of contemplative practices for teacher professional becoming? To respond to the research question an exploratory, qualitative, multiple case-study was conducted, informed by Heidegger’s hermeneutic phenomenology, Schatzki’s theory of social practices, and aspects of Buddhist philosophy. Seven beginning teachers with an existing commitment to contemplative practice were recruited and participated in interviews, metaphoric drawing, school-based fieldwork, and shared researcher-participant meditation over the period of one year. Study participants engaged in a range of contemplative practices, which were associated with a variety of altered experiences of time, space, self and world. These practices and experiences were woven into forms of identity work, via which participants imagined themselves as teachers in a context characterised by uncertainty and in-betweenness (theorised here as liminality). Participants identified various forms of overlap, harmony, and friction between the worlds of teaching and contemplative practices. Beyond being a technique of self-care, contemplative practices played both a constructive and deconstructive role with respect to teacher identity. As constructive, contemplative practices inflected the purposes of teaching, and also grounded the cultivation of virtues (including calm, compassion and curiosity). As deconstructive, contemplative practices of self-inquiry facilitated a loosening of the habitual aspects of the self, which I conceive as un-becoming. This work culminated in the phenomenon of presence—an aware, responsive and connected mode of being—which, at times, was inhibited by the social and institutional structures of education. The interpretation of the empirical material shows how contemplative practices have significant implications for beginning teacher identity and practice. They operate as nodes of stability within the liminal spaces of teacher professional becoming. However, paradoxically, they emphasise that the un-making of the teacher-self may be just as important as the making of the teacher-self, captured in the notion of professional-becoming-as-un-becoming. Overall, the findings suggest that educational policymakers and school leaders assessing the value of mindfulness need to be aware of the broader web of practices to which it is historically and philosophically related. The findings also suggest substantial opportunities for the integration of aspects of contemplative practice, as supporting forms of reflection and radical reflexivity, into teacher education and professional development. However, there remain a range complex issues which need to be addressed in doing so.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2979565415
Cites: 345
Cited by: 5
Related to: 10