Work

Biobanking and data transfer between the EU and Cape Verde, Mauritius, Morocco, Senegal, and Tunisia: adequacy considerations and Convention 108

Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: Convention 108 is the first international data protection treaty. Upon entry into force of the Protocol modernizing the convention in the near future, Convention 108 will become Convention 108+ and will gain the potential to become a global standard-setter in the field of data protection. Even though Convention 108 and Convention 108+ have close ties with the European Union, Convention 108+ can be expected to have different impacts in regard to adequacy assessments in different national legal orders, and hence varying potential to contribute to building data transfer avenues for biobank research. An adequacy decision is not a decision on the adequacy of the data protection regime stricto sensu but, in fact, requires the adequacy of the legal system in the respective country to be in place and its capability to uphold the fundamental right to privacy as a key pillar of a democratic legal system where a data subject has adequate seclusion not only from other individuals but also from the state. In order to enable sustainable collaborative research, in addition to raising the data protection bar and strengthening biobanking in Cape Verde, Mauritius, Morocco, Senegal, and Tunisia, the efforts should go further and strengthen democracy, human rights, and rule of law. Biobanking is a privacy-intrusive activity. With advances in biobanking and its associated science, the intensity and depth of privacy intrusions are increasing. These intrusions can occur in a number of ways, which can be largely divided into the following three groups: first, through the sample and data collection, and in particular, the approach that is being used for participant recruitment, types of specimen, and how they are obtained; secondly, through data processing during research; and thirdly, during data and sample sharing. The latter two steps have in particular advanced in the last decades. Now, not only is it common for the sample annotation and storage location to have been digitalized1 but also for various software solutions to have been operationalized in order to support biobanks in administrative and research practices.2 Relatively recently virtual biobanks have also become common,3 which allows for easier and faster data exchange. Finally, data depositing in compliance with, inter alia, data sharing and open science requirements has also given rise to considerable privacy-related questions.4 Data and sample sharing is key pre-requisite for biomedical advances. Just as a sufficient amount and a high enough quality of biospecimen and data have the potential to accelerate translational research and clinical discoveries, their lack can stall research and limit scientific advances.5 Sharing concerns exist both in research collaborations between actors within the European Union (EU), in which Biobanking and BioMolecular Resources Research Infrastructure-European Research Infrastructure Consortium European Court of Human Rights General Data Protection Regulation (BMRI-ERIC) has a prominent role to play,6 as well as between EU countries and third countries, for example, states in Africa, in which several considerable biobank capacity-building initiatives have taken place, or international organizations such as IARC BioBank, which is among the largest, most varied, and richest collections of samples in the world.7 In addition to the potential to further scientific advances, which is in the EU’s interest,8 data and sample sharing EU countries with third countries can contribute to research in regard to states in Africa, it a to building through which the to science can be and for the of research to it is that data sharing is only should for the in the EU be to data from the third countries, and in particular, states within Africa, but they should also be to transfer data from to research in a pre-requisite for sustainable collaborations is data transfer and the and its data protection has a particular role to in the EU data protection requirements are through the they are also other for example, through Convention 108 and privacy protection in international human such as the of Human Rights on and Rights and European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights will be recently Convention 108 has been and the EU has given to its to to the EU data protection regime is the and most the high is to be to data in biobank research data are being in the of the data from EU data as well for example, the EU data data are being to third countries or international has been through and data transfer in the for three data sharing avenues and in and can be used for data transfer it that adequacy is the most for data and sample as well as sustainable and to the the European has adequacy of which two are and the with are in and adequacy are of has been with to countries in several states in Africa, both in and the are to Convention has the Protocol the Convention for the Protection of with regard to of Data will to a to with the data protection of Convention 108+ of Convention 108 as the states that are to Convention 108 can be expected to to the Protocol in the near Convention as well as Convention not only has a particular in the national legal of the EU but also for the EU adequacy the potential for Convention 108+ to be a to further adequacy which become the for building sustainable data transfer avenues and the of scientific research. Convention 108+ be a through which between the data protection in the EU and third countries, in Africa, be In of the to Convention 108+ can in adequacy decision and contribute to building sustainable data transfer avenues and research in the of the ties between the EU and the of in the of data protection. it on to the EU adequacy requirements the and to the that Convention 108+ contribute to adequacy In particular is on countries that have to Convention that it can contribute to the data protection in the respective third countries and international organizations that are or will become its to the convention in is not An adequacy decision is not a decision on the adequacy of the data protection regime stricto requires adequacy of the legal system in the respective country to be in place and for it to have the capability to uphold the fundamental right to privacy as a key pillar of a democratic legal system where the of a data subject adequate seclusion not only from other individuals but also from the which is the of Convention in addition to raising the data protection bar and biobanking the to strengthen democratic human rights, and rule of the of a legal order in in the it with the of data in the last its to the field to have been in the of data protection in the that is The of has not only its key in the of data Convention but also a number of other to the on data and in the field of strengthening the data protection regime and also requirements to scientific research. Convention 108 has a particular with the is the EU data protection regime has its in Convention of the EU are to Convention and hence through to the convention have their in the in which the EU has also In from the of the EU data protection regime it has been in the of the EU not to a where the EU are to with the for the EU’s in the of Convention the is and is the of of a can be for Convention 108 and Convention 108+ and EU a and with considerable to the to Convention 108+ not to the of the EU legal In of the Convention that will Convention 108+ is to the European Data Protection and not the Court of of the European Union among the that the EU can gain are the of to other of the of that are not of the as well as of and international which is that the EU to it is a of strengthening the of a of European legal and of strengthening the These also contribute to the role of Convention 108 in the and are in with the role of as a to the EU’s the EU the of Convention 108+ can be expected to be in two different first, the EU secondly, the third The the EU can be a into the The of a requires that the the EU are to a can be the EU to the of the of the EU’s or for the be to the 108 and both being data protection within the of between the EU and its EU are to Convention 108 for and they have the the EU has given to its to with the of the the EU has to Convention following it will be of EU and will be the EU and the as EU has well been in that compliance with from the the within the in to the which has for the of the that the EU to Convention in as EU in the of data protection the between Convention 108+ and the EU to The will only in as a particular is not a of the which the of Convention 108+ with the the third countries, particular is to a particular role to Convention 108 in adequacy which is only Convention 108 a for the Data Protection it be expected that states that have to Convention 108 will have in their data protection legal to in the EU Data Protection also be to the and Convention as further the Protocol has been to of the it can be expected that states that have to the Protocol and become to Convention 108+ will have in their data protection legal to in the EU in the the a particular role to Convention 108 but not to Convention states that from the international the third country or international has the should of from the third or international in or in particular in to the protection of as well as the of such In particular, the third to the of Convention of for the Protection of with regard to the of Data and its Protocol should be taken into The should the the of protection in third countries or international The of Convention 108 in a in a for the of Convention 108+ is that the Protocol for on two the of the is is and to given the between 108 and the is sufficient in the EU data protection requirements the adequacy will be in the of adequacy is of the three avenues through which data to third countries or international organizations The other avenues are and in among which of particular to the of biobanking are of An adequacy decision that the has that the third a or or within that third or the international in adequate of of adequacy decision the of data between the EU and the respective international or third country as as the adequacy decision is not the the to on adequacy that a or a or within the third country or international adequate of protection of that for a for a and regard to in the third country or international the is the to of in the third country or international that the of the adequacy where or the respective following the the are in the role of a of the data on adequacy and can a to the and adequacy decision is a of building sustainable collaborations and data transfer as it considerable in the of adequacy decision other transfer are with its example, a considerable on the which is a biobank or in research not be to the of a between the and which is that not exist in a research Finally, to of that research in that are as a or the EU In the of a transfer on adequacy the are with on the in the of a data further or other are it be expected that the that the adequacy decision has not been or the European or the the adequacy can be as a through which to international and it is a through which and the are as the respective third country or international the adequacy has a the Data Protection in and to the has and two adequacy which on is decision a with are advanced be the first adequacy decision the number of is the of the in regard to that has been in third has the European has to the of of data protection in the countries for adequacy but have not been data the number of countries in adequacy decision are also An adequacy decision that the of data protection in the respective third country or international or in a protection to that within the be to that and are in place to that the of protection of the is not data are to the third the Data Protection the the key for as the of the is not and other be The requirements in can be divided into three groups: and and international will be in the should be that in are a of and the is not with for their the of the European not the to in regard to adequacy which and is the European Data Protection with is of as a to the EU requirements for adequacy in third countries and international in can sufficient of the and for adequacy that are the of the European requires the to into a of the rule of for human and fundamental both and national and and the of to as well as the of such data protection and for the transfer of data to third country or international which are with in that country or international as well as and data subject and administrative and for the data data are being The rule of and for human and fundamental are of the EU and as common of EU for human and fundamental EU the and the of the in the EU legal order is of is not the with the of the rule of law. Even though the to the rule of it has been the In has in and they the of legal legal and protection of of and the of In it has been that the of rule of such as the of legal that the is and and that its be for as well as compliance with the the of are of that have the right to the the of decision or other national the to of EU in the of the EU it that the are subject to of the of their with the and the of requires the to and national and and the of to as well as the of such In has that also be to the legal for the of to the the following European first, that processing should be on and secondly, that the of and with regard to the to be thirdly, that should and that to be to the These requirements are in with the EU on data protection as a for and to is in be in the of the data and requires the protection and for the transfer of data to third country or international which are with in that country or international as well as and data subject and administrative and for the data data are being and data subject and administrative and for the data data are being should be has been well that the privacy and data protection on third countries are not sufficient in the EU and that for of the right to data protection be in the third or international legal not in are and how the should These requirements are further in which states that third or international system a number of and data protection and These have been in three groups: and in particular The the The first is is expected that data protection are in the national law. should not have to the but should and be with the in the European data protection The is for and processing for In which data be and should be in a The third is the The is the data quality and The is the data The is the and The is the which requires that individuals be of the of the processing of their data in a and it is that to right for in particular can for example, to national and or other of as is the with of the The is the right of and which in be The is on that should not be the adequate of protection of data in the respective country or international In the of of the data from the EU be to that are for of data in the of adequacy of data should only place for and and as as is a legal for that The are expected to be to types of three the protection of of data and data are In that the in and are of particular in it is to data for the of the data subject be given a right to to such a processing of where and it place only in the third country legal In such a the should for to the data An is a key of the fundamental right to data protection as in from in adequacy not only the of is but also that it is in and data protection be not only through the with adequate but also through the of and raising among data and processing data on their of their and and among data of their and the of as in and other compliance role in for the data protection the data protection system support to data in the of their as well as to the of the data in regard to which of and of is of particular Finally, as from should be taken of international the third country or international has or other from or as well as from its in or in particular in to the protection of In the on the international the third country or international has the from in or in particular in to the protection of as well as the of such in regard Convention 108 is of given the that the Protocol in Convention 108 in with the and the high requirements in it is that Convention 108 will be sufficient in the respective it well be for a that has not to the Protocol but has its legal system to the adequacy the its entry into Convention 108 will become Convention The to the of the convention in considerable the of with a to to the that advances in have and to of its The inter have the of the convention through data protection in human and the for the protection of the human and fundamental of also that the right to data protection be with other human and fundamental the of to and the of the global the fundamental of for privacy and protection of and the for between the of the In that the the convention as data protection with for a global key the The and of the convention have been on the protection of with regard to processing of their The in the of the convention inter the from to of also the of and through the the of of the convention is that the are of the of types of processing from the of of the Now, the convention can be only data processing in the of or The to and strengthen the of the to in their the of or and to to and in the of the of national also and the to the of data processing and quality of data the with data protection in the the of is not but the in to the legal for the processing of the the of a approach to of data and which they can be In with the the convention several of data and the latter of which is to a high of data protection in The convention the data and in with the it requires that its that to the data which with the and fundamental of data the of the of which to the data right to and of the and largely and to the The for the data have become of the data that in to in of the a right to which is a fundamental of the that is in of the The of with such fundamental in of the as of the and data and have a place in of Convention The also of the and which inter the of the of the convention can be and the of which in is operationalized to the of the to and place on and and to the of of the convention as to of the convention as In the as the convention to of that which is the its The to the of data to within the the as well as between the of the convention and third The convention the of of data among the and to is and that the transfer to or from that other to a to the of the as well as international to which a is a In regard to third countries, it the that of protection on the of Convention is and for two avenues through which of protection can be first, of that or international international secondly, or are in and and the in the transfer and further In the as the it also allows in of the convention to of the Protocol of Convention not to be in of a last the is not it is as data transfer legal These requirements to a considerable and such in the of scientific research as national the of is of Finally, it the of of to the and that the data the of the or the of and the such or subject to of the of the the role of the has been and the of their that in of the to Convention 108 has been The of is in as it in regard to in their The are to the and have the to with data subject and as it of the and The taken be subject to through the The are also to of privacy and regard to the protection of the of the In their and is and should they In regard to the to their the are to that the have the The and of the are to be and the is to be its of and a on the The are to and to the as well as to the General of the of of the national or The a and with to the for the of their and of their In order to limit the of of the is of the as is their to a on of a data subject of the in their be of In regard to other of and the should on the Finally, the of Convention 108 the Convention and its role and are inter to it and and in the of data to Convention Convention 108+ such as the is is to the is in as a concerns privacy and a of the it is to be in of privacy and have the potential to be the is that Convention 108+ considerable to the which be to to the has the from the in modernizing the are between the two example, Convention 108+ not of national the is and on the Convention 108+ for its to how it will be the EU it will be operationalized through the third countries will for is a through the Convention 108+ that the are to of Convention In the of on the of the in how various adequacy as well as the varying to different third it is to a adequacy not of that states in that are to Convention 108 and are expected to become to Convention 108+ on their of though Cape Verde, Mauritius, Morocco, Senegal, and have to Convention its and is the first of states to the are considerable in the data protection and how that has been operationalized in example, data protection have been different in to or that has been adequacy and to be example, the Data Protection of Cape is from the Data Protection from and the of from of and its of These not the adequacy is from and has a Data Protection which also not the adequacy Even though in a with a to a to the has not been into In though the Data Protection of Cape is from the a number of with the and the Data Protection of considerable data protection requirements with the The states of have that are of to the of data protection. Cape and are of the of has a on Data Protection from requires its to for the of data storage and and is in the it is the Data Protection and hence national that the with the EU data protection the considerable between the data protection of and Cape the other states such as Mauritius, Morocco, and not have data protection the is of as is of the privacy rights, which to have been a in example, in the it that in and a and in Tunisia, in different states of privacy has has been in have that are not of the of their of in Cape to be on the of democracy, rule of and human In a number of and Even though the Union is to further the protection of human in the and Cape Verde, Mauritius, Senegal, and are to in only Mauritius, Senegal, and have to the Protocol and have to the of the and hence only they can be a for the of the human in their national legal and the states of have different and the with the EU have role to In states that a international can be as a considerable in strengthening human rights, as is the of Senegal, for In and have through the that exist in the can be with, for example, Cape and where a democratic of The of is to to Convention 108+ in adequacy in third countries and as a for building sustainable data transfer avenues and research in the of the the EU has a considerable in Convention 108+ and in convention being in with EU law. also the the of has to Convention 108+ and global of the data protection and to can be to be it a number of it also These to the of the requirements in Convention 108+ and the for the and be as the of on the of the respective third countries that are has been that adequacy is not data protection stricto sensu but data protection not only the requirements of data is and how protection is but also the legal system in which data protection Convention 108+ has considerable with the and key as in it is in to a third country or international to convention not only to be operationalized but also operationalized in that is of a fundamental right to data protection. should be it is that it is also that is In a can be between the third countries that are of the of and that are the of rule of and human have been of a particular of are to the and states have a to the protection of human in their legal it is the that can states in the protection has not been in a particular the has considerable in data protection which can be with the approach the which in not a privacy In the Union the Convention on and Data convention is not in force only and have taken steps to the has Cape has also in the from the data protection where the adequacy within the European as well as other but not the Union is among the organizations with which the to its in the of data the of the legal in data protection as a right and to uphold data protection is not only a of human and data protection is also of of the respective countries, as as their are be further example, among the states of to the on and is for strengthening the rule of but it has only been Cape Verde, Mauritius, Senegal, and and not has not the the potential to strengthen has not been exist the capability to uphold the fundamental right to privacy as a key pillar of a democratic legal system where of a data subject a of not only from other individuals but also from the it be to the EU data as in the in the third the efforts in addition to raising the data protection bar and strengthening biobanking in Cape Verde, Mauritius, Morocco, Senegal, and Tunisia, should go further and strengthen democracy, human rights, and rule of law. is and to states be to such and how they Convention 108+ will only be of as a to strengthen data protection but not of in the the for the European the the of different adequacy will which it can the for not adequacy to states that have in a system in place that is of a fundamental right to data protection. a different scientific research and building is a EU to the for adequacy in of scientific research, in the such as
Institution: Lund University
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,850
OpenAlex ID: W3012255142
FWCI: 2.355
Cites: 13
Cited by: 20
Related to: 10