The Role of Criminalistics Mentality and Fundamental Questions of Criminalistics in the Investigation
Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: This study analyses the significance and raison of criminalistics thinking and the fundamental questions of criminalistics.Criminalistics and the defined principles and recommendations have an indispensable role in the understanding of the events of the past.Key words: criminalistics way of thinking, fundamental questions of criminalistics, specific profiling, investigation, evidentiary measures Successful combat against crime is inconceivable without criminalistics.One of the measures of the cognitive methods is the criminalistics attitude that is strongly connected to legal norms and based on the approach to understand the objective truth of the past and on the objective to establish material truth. 1 Fundamental questions of criminalistics play a significant role in the comprehension of past events.2 Combat against crime must analyse the fundamental issues of criminalistics and the system of general statutory provisions jointly, since answering the fundamental questions of criminalistics largely assists both the investigation and the successful evidentiary procedures.Thinking is one of the forms of cognitive activities.Investigation, as a cognitive procedure is based on procedural regulations.The criminalistics way of thinking sees through investigation procedure, from the state of planning, during which members of the authority have to reconstruct the past event in theory, and they have to establish the objective truth upon casual connection between cause and effect.Understanding of truth is a multilevel process whereas the fundamental questions of criminalistics, raster investigation and evidentiary procedures have key importance in the cognizance of the relevant event.JánosLakatos sees criminalistics thinking as one of the cognitive measures 'that is also a specific solution to the problems of investigation'.3 Specific characteristics of the criminalistics way of thinking 4 usually see through the investigation, which consists of the following components: reconstructive way of thinking based of legal norms, the application of versions, logical methods, intuition and phantasy, empathy, doubt, case-type skills, experience, collective wisdom self-assessment and coincidence.In his study titled 'Brain efforts of criminal professionals.Theart and boundaries of criminalistics conclusions' Erich Anuschutrefers to the importance of logic besides 'experience' and 'simple common sense'.As for the criminalist without proper skills of logic the author states that he must surely be busy speculating on difficult cases, without any success guaranteed, unless coincidence or goodwill 'give him a hint'.5 1 Budaházi, Árpád, Polygraph Examinations.Blessing or Curse, 2005, Lap Lambert Academic Publishing, Saarbrücken, p. 5 2 We must mention that the frames of the criminalistics way of thinking are continuously broadening with the development of sciences.Lately, several new scientific methods become part ofthe criminalistics attitude that were formerly unknown to this field.For example, let's just refer to criminal geography.See more in Mátyás,Szabolcs (2018): A bűnözésföldrajz vitás kérdései.Földrajzi Közlemények (Debated question of criminal geography, 2018, Geographical Announcements), Budapest,
Author: Dr. Endre Nyitrai
Institution: Ludovika University of Public Service
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W3036089016
