Year: 1999
Type: article
Abstract: This article is about the design of an antitrust rule.The central question is whether antitrust should employ a structured or truncated analysis rather than an unstructured review of the reasonableness of defendant's conduct in evaluating a monopolization allegation.This type of question frequently arises in thinking about Sherman Act § 1;' this article considers the question with respect to Sherman Act § 2 doctrine.The project of identifying appropriate truncated judicial decision rules is consistent with an economic approach to antitrust enforcement.Indeed, Chicago school commentators have embraced it by proposing new per se rules or structured decision rules intended to make antitrust law more economically rational.2 The tradeoffs involved in choosing between truncated and unstructured review can be set forth briefly.All truncated rules amount to instructing courts not to listen to certain kinds of evidence.3 Their use thus raises the possibility that the court will get the answer wrong.4 And there is a fairness concern: why not look at evidence that one party thinks would be relevant?The answer may be that it could be very costly to consider that evidence, and doing so may not alter the outcome.That is, the additional evidence may be difficult to uncover, expensive for other parties to confront in an adversarial setting, and hard for a fact-finder to evaluate-and in the end, the court's decision may be unlikely to vary from the outcome that would have arisen without considering it.In short, in some cases bright-line rules can reduce the transactions costs of operating the judicial system without markedly increasing the likelihood or costs of judicial errors.5 The key to developing good trun-* Washington College of Law, American University, and formerly Director, Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission.The views expressed are not necessarily those of the Commission or any individual Commissioner.
Source: bepress Legal Repository
Author: Jonathan B. Baker
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3045697729
