Work

Memory production, vandalism, violence: Civil society and lessons from a short life of a monument to Stalin

Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: On September 15th 2016, the leaders of youth group the "Russian Spirit," 2 unveiled a monument to Stalin in the Siberian city Surgut, located in central Russia.The bust was erected a few meters away from a display board, which states, "In some time at this place there will be a monument to the victims of Soviet Repressions." 3 Someone poured red paint over Stalin's bust twice and wrote "henchman" on the side.The first time vandalism occurred was the day after the installation.The local municipalities removed the monument three weeks after due to the absence of state authorization and also because the monument lacked "public toleration."The defacement of the statue and the formulation of the city council of Surgut, triggered an inquiry on what is "public toleration" and how should one react to monuments of perpetrators in a public domain?Should the memorial exist, in the spirit of toleration of the views which disturb, outrage, and lack respect for the millions of victims?Or is the approach of the municipalities that banned the monument and the "good" civil society that repeatedly vandalized the monument appropriate?I argue for the latter.Traditionally, civil society is perceived as a "watchdog" of society, a guarantor of democracy, and as an inherently positive institution.This work calls for a reimagination of the role of civil society engaged with memory initiatives and argues that limits to toleration of "uncivil" civil society exist.We should not presume that civil society initiatives are always respectful of victims, tolerance, and diversity.An analysis of the qualities or "textures" and "temperature,"of civil society gives a more accurate picture of civil society operating in a particular milieu (Krygier, 2002).This work assesses the posts on social media, the official website of the organization "Russian Spirit," newspaper articles, and secondary interviews from September 2015 (a date before the erection of the monument), to the present day to examine the qualities of the civil society.The paper first provides a working definition of the term "civil society."I then examine the power dynamics behind memory politics through the history and historiography of memory production and the specifics of Stalinist and anti-Stalinist attitudes in the Soviet and post-Soviet Russia.This paper further outlines the characteristics of "uncivil" civil
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,500
OpenAlex ID: W3048202128
FWCI: 1.733
Cites: 42
Cited by: 8
Related to: 10