Work

Living with the legacy of impunity: lessons for South Africa about truth, justice and crime in Brazil

Year: 1997
Type: other
Abstract: It was never necessary in Brazil to institutionalize a legal Apartheid because, in addition to social and economic discrimination... petty authorities and the `Do you know to whom you are speaking? ' syndrome always has a role in containing black and poor people in civil society (Paulo Sérgio Pinheiro, 1994). This article focuses on how Brazil dealt with and failed to deal with its authoritarian past, and what lessons this experience may hold for South Africa. The central focus is on victim support groups in both countries and examines their primary concerns: their need for the truth; and their demands for justice. The experiences of Brazil in these areas are examined, with references to equivalent experiences in Argentina and Chile, and lessons for South Africa are extracted. Finally the link between past human rights violations, impunity and rising crime is discussed. RESUMEN Este documento subraya la forma en que Brasil enfrentó su pasado autoritario y fracasó, y la enseñanza que ello entraña para Sudáfrica. El énfasis estriba en los grupos de apoyo a las víctimas en ambos países y sus preocupaciones fundamentales: sus demandas por el reconocimiento de las atrocidades cometidas en el pasado, ya sea de manera simbólica o pecuniaria; la necesidad de conocer la verdad y su sed de justicia. Se analiza la experiencia brasileña en estas esferas con referencia a experiencias equivalentes en Argentina y Chile; y, se señalan las lecciones que se pudieran derivar para Sudáfrica. Finalmente, se expone el vínculo entre las violaciones pasadas de los derechos humanos, la impunidad y el incremento de la tasa de criminalidad.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3082011
Cites: 10
Cited by: 44
Related to: 9