Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation, which examines the theme of influencing through language in multinational university students' L2 debating, belongs to the field of sociolinguistics, applied linguistics, second language acquisition (SLA), pragmatics, and social semiotics.The study is based on debates video-recorded at the University of Kuopio, now part of the University of Eastern Finland, in 2006, and focuses on investigation of the use of argumentation strategies, the use of rhetorical devices, use of persuasive discourse, and multimodal/paralinguistic methods.Cross-cultural phenomena in debate situations are also examined, and Finnish and non-Finnish students are compared.The study has been conducted from the perspective of language centre teachers with the aim of contributing to the development of innovative university-level L2 instruction in oral skills at language centres in order to promote university students' L2 (= first foreign language) oral proficiency and raise their awareness of cross-cultural differences in intercultural communication.The data of the study consist of multinational university students' (N=31) debates, which were video-recorded in a university setting.The subjects (21 Finnish, 12 non-Finnish) were students at the Department of Clinical Medicine and Nutrition, University of Kuopio.These students had reached the final stage of their two-semester university course aiming at completion of the Master of Public Health (MPH) degree.The MPH studies had covered most of the themes in the field of Public Health and had consisted of lectures, seminars, essay writing, small-group sessions, and individual presentations.The language of the MPH course had been English, which was the first foreign language for all the students.The debates analysed in this dissertation were the final task and requirement of the MPH course.The non-Finnish course leader had chosen the two topics for the debates: 1) Restriction of alcohol under the age of eighteen encourages alcohol abuse, and 2) Abstinence is the best possible way to prevent HIV/AIDS.The students, who did not know the topics of the debates before entering the video-room, had been divided into 4 groups and these groups were split into two subgroups.In each subgroup there was at least one non-Finnish student.The students were asked to act out the roles of either proponents or opponents in the debates.The vi research questions were the following: 1) What kinds of verbal and nonverbal strategies and means of argumentation do the learners use? 2) How do the students utilize different nonverbal means of argumentation? and 3) What kinds of cross-cultural phenomena are linked with the debate situation?The themes and features to be studied in this dissertation were investigated in three different studies.Study I examined argumentation strategies.Study II investigated multimodal/paralinguistic features, and Study III investigated the elements of persuasive discourse.In Study I, the research method was qualitative, in Study II and in Study III both qualitative and quantitative methods were used.The results show that the students acted out their roles fairly well and were active in their argumentative roles.The most common argumentation strategies were the use of straightforward statements, evidence, statistical information, facts, examples, logical reasoning, repetition, restructuring, questions, repeated questions and use of emphatic words.The most frequently used paralinguistic tools were gestures, head nods, body movements, eye-gaze, smiling, laughter, and assertive, intonational tone of voice.In cross-cultural comparison, the Finnish students used questions and repeated questions more than the non-Finnish students did; and the non-Finnish students used more paralinguistic features than the Finnish students did.Only smiling was used more by the Finnish students.A strong collaborative strategy clearly prevailed in both proponents' and opponents' groups.In summary, the results indicate that debating is an effective means of practising the demanding command of oral skills in various situations, and that role-plays are efficient tools for practising debating.Argumentation strategies can be taught by applying Aristotle's three devices, ethos, logos, and pathos, and by eliciting and emphasizing the importance of paralinguistic features in oral communication.Awareness of paralinguistic means and the ways of influencing are useful and important tools and should be taught during L2 oral skills courses in university language centres.Similarly, instruction in pragmatic conversational skills should be included in the language teaching curricula.
Author: Maija Metsämäki
Language: English
Subfield: Language and Linguistics
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
Funders: Helsingin Yliopisto, Jyväskylän Yliopisto
OpenAlex ID: W3097106905
