The Pro Homine Principle’s Role in Regulating the Relationship between Conventionality Control and Constitutionality Control
Year: 2017
Type: article
Abstract: This article conducts a comparative analysis of the American and European Conventions on Human Rights to review the relationship between conventionality control and constitutionality control assumed by domestic courts. First, the analysis negates the monist pyramid model by pointing out the limits of the supremacy of international law and constitution. Given the integration of conventionality control into constitutionality control in practice, this study instead presents the normative framework of the trapezium model, crowning the common values recognized by both national constitutions and international law. This research also contributes to clarifying the pro homine principle, a fitting concept to the trapezium schema, focusing on the most favourable treatment for individuals. Specifically, it proves the principle’s double function to offensively pierce or defensively safeguard the boundary between international and domestic legal orders. Finally, it argues that in cases of conflicting rights between different individuals, the pro homine principle relativizes an absolute protection of certain rights to strike balance between them. In essence, conventionality control and constitutionality control should be coordinated by the open-minded, substance-oriented, pro homine principle within the pluralist trapezium, in lieu of the principle of the closed, formal supremacy of international law or constitution within the monist pyramid.
DOI: 10.1093/ejil/chx030
Author: Yota Negishi
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: pro homine principle, conventionality control, constitutionality control, human rights treaties, American Convention on Human Rights, European Convention on Human Rights, supremacy of international law, constitutional supremacy, relationship between international and domestic law, conflict of rights, national courts
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W3124631378
