“Critical Buddhism” (Hihan Bukkyō) and the debate concerning the 75-fascicle and 12-fascicle Shōbōgenzō texts
Year: 1994
Type: article
Abstract: One of the main issues in the recent movement known as Critical Buddhism (hihan bukkyõ) is the question of which version of the Shõbõgenzõ represents Dõgen’s authentic philosophical message. Critical Buddhism has rejected the conventional emphasis on the priority of the 75-fascicle version, which contains the famous philosophical essays on “Buddha-nature ” (Busshõ) and “Being-Time ” (Uji). Instead it empha-sizes that the 12-fascicle Shõbõgenzõ, which was written toward the end of Dõgen’s life and contains mainly practical instructions for monks in training, is the real or authentic text because of its critique of original-enlightenment thought and consistent focus on karmic causality. This paper examines the Critical Buddhist view in the light of responses by tra-ditional Dõgen scholars. The debate is framed and evaluated in the larger context of Buddhist scholasticism and hermeneutics in which scholars try to reinterpret medieval sources from a classical or foundational standpoint and in terms of distinctively modern concerns.
Author: Steven Heine
Language: English
Topic: Indian and Buddhist Studies
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W326411069
