Work

Track Maintenance Costs and Economies of Density: An Analysis of the Speed Factored Gross Tonnage Model

Year: 1993
Type: article
Abstract: It has traditionally been assumed in the railroad industry that unit costs decrease as traffic volume increases. This assumption is behind the trend to multi-car rates, unit trains, and the consolidation of more and more traffic on fewer mainlines. However, there is some reason to believe that economies of density, at least in maintenance of way (MOW), may not be as extensive as has been assumed. One widely used MOW cost model is the Speed Factored Gross Tonnage (SFGT) model. SFGT assumes that MOW costs are related to the square root of traffic density, producing a continuously declining marginal cost as traffic increases. SFGT has been used in a number of ICC cases concerning the incremental cost of new coal and grain traffic. The result has been lost revenue for the railroads. This paper will examine the assumptions embodied in the SFGT model. From economic, engineering, strategic, and statistical viewpoints, it will be shown that continuously declining marginal costs are an impossibility, and that the assumption of continuously declining costs may have had serious consequences for the railroad industry's strategic planning. Alternative, and more reasonable, cost functions will be proposed. One possible alternative MOW cost allocation model formulation will be presented and discussed. The conclusion of the paper is that the railroad industry in North America has likely reached a point where marginal track maintenance cost is increasing, rather than decreasing.
Language: English
Subfield: Transportation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W32795670
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by: 4
Related to: 10